/ Electronic shifting
I've seen people on here talking about it but the costs are astronomical with just the groupset costing more than twice my budget for the whole bike.
SO, can I ask.... does electronic shifting add anything or is it just companies desperately trying to get one over each other or just the need to provide something new to spend money on?
I've never found changing gear that challenging to be honest. Also I have to wonder about maintenance and repairs while on the road.
£1800 ultegra di2
Thanks.... I'm not really after one myself (too worried about a dead battery) more the benefits of such a system.
No cable drag,having to adjust cable tensions,sticky cables. Cleaner looking frames,more options for frame builders due to smaller holes reqd for cable routing.
Batteries last for a long time.(1-2000 miles depending on gear shifts and can be charged 500 times) They are self adjusting also so no annoying trimming the front mech
Completely effortless shifting. (i would agree it is exactly hardwork on cable operated but it will be noticeably easier)
Disadvantages - cost,heavier than equivalent groupset,a wire could easily get damaged in a crash unlike a sturdy cable outer,
Not got them but they are the things I have read and thought of myself
It's absolutely not necessary, but if you shop around you can get it for not a lot more than the equivalent cable groupset. Over time you'll save a few quid by not having to replace cables each year but in general it is more expensive and a bit heavier.
The battery won't go flat unless you're daft - you get a warning when it's getting below 25% (which is still good for a couple of long days), then the front stops shifting so you can ride with just the rear gears for another 100 miles or so.
Maintenance "on the road" is easier than with a mechanical groupset - you can adjust the rear mech in 0.5mm increments as you're riding if you want. The rear mech has crash protection built in so it won't get smashed if you drop your bike on the drive side, but unless you have friction shifting anything that could happen to Di2 to make it a rescue job could happen to a normal set up - in most cases you'll be able to get home.
I'm seriously thinking about it on my next winter bike, as the lack of maintenance actually makes it even more appropriate for a winter bike - but I suspect my Mrs might have something to say about that...
the mechanical variants of the same groupset wouldnt be that much cheaper though.
It does seem increasingly viable as an option although still some way to go to being generally affordable.
Advantage seems to be, particularly for the front, faster and smoother shifting. Of course it would depend on the cyclist on how much that really matters, for a pro on the every little bit helps it might but for, say me, getting more miles in would be far better.
Having carefully adjusted my kit, I still spent a few frantic minutes fighting with my front shifter as it constantly mis-shifted.
Still, I got to meet Sean Kelly and Malcolm Elliot.
One of the girls I was pegalling with has Di2 on her Felt - she loves it.
Friction is good for cummuting and winter bikes too, you just need to lube the cables when shifting becomes stiff enough to be annoying, at least that's how long I leave it. (:-))
There isn't really any benefit other than a nicer shifting experience and no graunchy changes. definitely a "nice to have". I wouldn't have it had I not changed my bike earlier this year, but I'm glad I have.
Elsewhere on the site
This years ROCfest will be slightly different. We've decided to run a Climbing Festival, not just a competition! Over... Read more
Climbing Technology’s range of winter hardware continues to grow and for winter 2014 they have a crampon in the range to... Read more
F ounded in 1993, Mountain Hardwear are a pretty young mountaineering clothing and equipment manufacturer but are also one of... Read more
Steve Dunning has made what is likely the tenth ascent of The New Statesman, the classic and bold gritstone arete at the Cow... Read more
At a bar in Llanberis an old man chimed in And I thought he was out of his head Being a young man I just laughed it off When... Read more