/ NEW REVIEW: The Beta Stick Compact
Read more at http://www.ukclimbing.com/gear/review.php?id=5115
i thought it was april 1st for a minute....
This in my opinion is not a review but simply an advert. I sport climb all the time and don't know many people that would recommend a beta-stick. They regularly break, the wire at the end normally expands and no longer works and the plastic rings down the shaft that hold in place when lengthened regularly lose their strength and place on the stick.
I don't mind if it is an advert but please call it that! A review would reasonably be expected to cover both pros and cons of the piece of equipment.
> This in my opinion is not a review but simply an advert. I sport climb all the time and don't know many people that would recommend a beta-stick. They regularly break, the wire at the end normally expands and no longer works and the plastic rings down the shaft that hold in place when lengthened regularly lose their strength and place on the stick.
> Possibly plenty of people wouldn't recommend without reservation but loads of sport climbers own them and find them very useful. There isn't really much competion in the end. To give a different slant I've had a compact for more than 5 year without any trouble - maybe the shorter lengths put less strain on the locking rings.
I agree there isn't much competition (I ended up making one myself from decathlon) and I do know a few people that have had no problems with them. However most people I know have had problems with theirs and certainly I think it is fair to say that they are not the most durable piece of kit in the world.
Yes they are useful I just think that this article is an advert and not a review. This discussion is much closer to a review wih both positives and negatives being made (mainly negatives from me!)
Its borderline cheeting realy isnt it ...
I just superglued it back onto the collar underneath when this happened to me. They seem to be a bit stingy on the glue in the factory.
Constructive comment there!
weenie sport climbers and they don't even have the balls to climb in lycra like their ancestors. Mark, please develop a mod so it can place the crucial sideways rp3
What review? It's just an advert!
I received some sound advice when I first started Sport routes which was verbatim on the Catwalk, "If I see you using a stick, I will break it".
But then, what does Mr Lovitt know. :-)
> What review? It's just an advert!
Same as all ukc reviews? Have they ever done a negative review? Never follow gear advice on here because its all positive. I dont find anything i read credible because its seems so fake spouting all the buzz words and phrases you get about all kit.
Some one add a review for some gear they went and used and it fell apart, didnt function that well or just didnt meet the marketed claims and performs just as averagely as everything else.
No it isn't actually. You will find critical reviews and you will find plenty of constructive comments about missing features, poorly designed features and other aspects of gear.
An example of how this works positively is the rope bag review we published initially in July 2011 and then updated in October 2011 - http://www.ukclimbing.com/gear/review.php?id=3625
In July 2011 we made some comments which were very critical of the Edelrid rope bag, and we also highlighted problems with the Moon Voyager bag and the Beal Combi Cliff bag. The Edelrid range was completely re-designed after this (it was on the cards anyway). This year at Friedrichshafen Ben Moon told me that he had responded to the comments we made about his bag and improved his new version. The comment about the dodgy zip puller for the Beal bag was also fed directly back to Beal by Lyon Equipment.
So in this case a critical but constructive review has had positive benefits for the manufacturers and end users. The rope bags still functioned as decent products, so they didn't need a hatchet job doing on them, but they weren't as good as they could be.
In the case of the Beta Stick - this review is an honest appraisal of using the device during a period of a few trips. If it falls apart over the next few trips then that wouldn't be good and we could add that to the review. So far it hasn't fallen apart so it would be wrong to say that in the review. It has performed exactly as designed and is a clever piece of kit. It is also a new model so it wouldn't be appropriate to judge it on the performance of old models.
I'm not sure about that Alan, I recall an advertorial for snake oil underwear with magical properties and water bottle cases which "lined up" water molecules to make them "more effective". Accappi?
The advertorial ended with a comment on how the stuff was being tested by ukc some of the testers being scientifically qualified. I do not recall seeing any results of these trials.
As for clip sticks; a bulldog clip, a few zip ties and dare I say it, a stick are all you really need. The components will fit in your pocket, never mind your hold luggage (assuming you don't have a special stick which simply must go to Spain with you).
> Its borderline cheeting realy isnt it ...
Get a long enough one and you're top roping :-)
... or alternatively, depending on where you go, you may be able to hire a proper full-sized Beta Stick when you're there for very little money and save the hassle of finding sticks and messing with bulldog clips.
Not sure about Spain but we certainly have them for rent for guests here in France.
> In the case of the Beta Stick - this review is an honest appraisal of using the device during a period of a few trips. If it falls apart over the next few trips then that wouldn't be good and we could add that to the review. So far it hasn't fallen apart so it would be wrong to say that in the review. It has performed exactly as designed and is a clever piece of kit. It is also a new model so it wouldn't be appropriate to judge it on the performance of old models.
Hmmm... fair enough it performed well over a couple of trips but I would say that it is fair then to make a comment in the review that longevity and durability can not be commented on. Also I would say that durability in pieces of equipment such as these is a key part of its function. When new Beta-Sticks work well and are very handy however it has been my experience and that of most sport climbers I know that they tend to start to fall apart quickly.
To say it is not fair to compare its durability with previous models does not really stack up in my opinion. It is very similar (almost identical) to previous models and I think a quick discussion with any of your friends that did a lot of sport climbing would show that many (not all I grant you) would say that they are very poor in the durability department.
As I have said previously I just don't think this is a fair review, it is just an advert.
Personally my opinion is that they are handy bits of equipment that work well when new. Size and lightness is good which makes taking them abroad viable. However they are not cheap and tend not to last well. Most people I know have had them break very quickly and have had to put tape around the locking rings. Obviously I know a few people who have had no problems with them. Overall if you want a clip-stick for use from the ground and don't need to take it up the route then I would make your own otherwise if you want something to take up a route or abroad then Beta-Sticks are a good option but be aware they need to be well cared for or they will break!
I think the problem with the article about the sticks is that it really doesn't have any negatives when most people who use or know about them would say there are plenty of negatives about them. This doesn't mean they are useless and that people shouldn't buy them, it just means that an honest and fair minded review would include these. In my opinion this would make the review much more credible and much more likely to influence/change my own (to be honest fairly negative) opinion towards them.
What do you mean there isnt much competition.
This Cost me £20 for the pole, and 2 hours work for figuring out the design and bending coat hanger into place. It will take even less time if u copy this or other designs online..
This is shorter than the Beta Stick when packed (65cm) and is almost 2 times as long (5 meters).
And the end is virtually indestructible. Even if it did break somehow, just find another wire coat hanger.
In the words of a wise Meerkat. Simples.
> Truly mind-boggling.
If your mind boggles at the fact that some people do things differently to you, you must find life very confusing...
> There isn't really much competion in the end.
No, which is a shame. I'm with Davo on this one, the longevity and quality of the Beta Stick is not great. I think a good quality clip stick wouldn't be much harder to make and I'd be happy to pay a reasonable price for it.
> What do you mean there isnt much competition.
> This Cost me £20 for the pole, and 2 hours work for figuring out the design and bending coat hanger into place. It will take even less time if u copy this or other designs online..
Which pole did you use?
Elsewhere on the site
Make the most of this months HALF PRICE OFFER on the Five Ten Guide Tennie Mid!! Designed as a hybrid approach and... Read more
The Christmas Gift Guide at Outside.co.uk Check out our top selection of Christmas Gift Ideas for climbers,... Read more
Halifax-based John Colton (see his UKC Gallery here) has an art exhibition in Courmayeur, Italy (the Italian side of Mont Blanc)... Read more
2012 saw the release of the beautiful first volume of definitive Yorkshire Gritstone climbing, produced by the YMC with Robin... Read more
Over the years I've been asked many times about work as a Rope Access technician, often by Instructors and Guides working for... Read more