/ Finest off shore mountain in British Isles?

This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
Trangia - on 11 Apr 2013
NMot withstanding the fact that "finest" is a subjective opinion, my vote goes to Sgurr nan Gillean
Douglas Griffin - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia:

Which one? :-)
fmck - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia:

Cir Mhor. #1
Douglas Griffin - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Douglas Griffin:

> Which one? :-)

Just to be clear what I meant, there's a Sgurr nan Gillean (and a Cuillin) on Rm as well.

To answer your question, Bl Bheinn for me.

Tim Chappell - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Douglas Griffin:

Whichever one I was up last. Which was, as it often is, Sgurr nan Gillean. The Skye one.

Sorley Maclean's favourite mountain, too.
paul-1970 - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia:

Boreray takes some beating in the awesome stakes.

An Clisham is a rather graceful hill, wonderful ridge to walk too.

The Quiraing is rather a unique and unmistakeable hill.
prog99 on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to fmck:
> (In reply to Trangia)
>
> Cir Mhor. #1

And for me.
Although thats mostly because I've never experienced good weather on Skye but seem to get lucky on Arran.
Steve Perry - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia: Sgurr nan Gillean for sure, my first ever Munro and my personal finest mountain. Blaven running in a close second.
Douglas Griffin - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Tim Chappell:

> Sorley Maclean's favourite mountain, too.

I'm not so sure.

"...agus ged a nochainn Prras,
de b' fhiach a ghealach-san gun Bhl Bheinn?"

"...and even if I came in sight of paradise,
what price its moon without Blaven?"

Sorley MacLean, An t-Eilean (The Island).

Gordon Stainforth - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia:

Sgurr nan Gillean
Sgurr Alasdair
Clach Glas
Blaven
Sgurr Thearlaich
Am Basteir
Cir Mhor
Marsco
Steve Perry - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Gordon Stainforth: Which did you find was the most photogenic Gordon, no matter what the conditions?
Tim Chappell - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Douglas Griffin:


I don't have time to go to the Poetry Section of our bookshelves and look this up, but I'm pretty sure he says Sgurr nan Gillean is the best mountain in the Cuillin, in "The Cuillin".
Douglas Griffin - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Tim Chappell:

Possibly. Will look it up when I get home.
johncoxmysteriously - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia:

I'd have thought 'the Cuillin' was an adequate answer.

Doug, that doesn't conjure up an image of being on Blaven so much (to me anyway) as being somewhere else looking at the moon with Blaven silhouetted against it.

jcm
Douglas Griffin - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to johncoxmysteriously:

Yes, you could be right there. One of the finest things about Blaven for me (apart from its own form) is the elevated view across to the main Cuillin ridge, especially from the Clach Glas-Bla Bheinn traverse.

It's also a stupendous-looking mountain when seen across Loch Slapin and from further up Strath Suardal, e.g. from Loch Cille Chriosd.

Though I agree, the Skye Cuillin in general is a place of superlatives.
Gordon Stainforth - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Steve Perry:

Gillean, Alasdair, Clach Glas, Am Basteir (and its famous Tooth) - all great mountain subjects. I became completely obsessed with the Basteir Tooth, I'll have to admit (so much so that Mike Lates called a new route on it 'Gordon's Wet Dream' :))
almost sane - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia:
Not sure if you would call them mountains, but for drama it is hard to beat Stac an Armin and Stac Lee.
Steve Perry - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Gordon Stainforth: Mike would ha ha!
SimonCRMC - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Tim Chappell:

Impressive memory - you're right.

An Sgurra Biorach sgurr as airde
An Sgurra nan Gillean sgurr an fhearr dhiubh
...
An sgurra Sgitheanach thar chaich dhiubh.

The Sgurr Biorach the highest sgurr,
but Sgurr nan Gillean the best sgurr,
...
the sgurr of Skye above the rest.
Douglas Griffin - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to SimonCRMC:

Ah, but that's only saying it's the best sgurr! ;-)
punj - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia: most of the cuillin both red and black would be contenders tbh

I would probably go for Gillean too
a lakeland climber on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to almost sane:

I was thinking of those as well.

ALC
SimonCRMC - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Douglas Griffin:
> (In reply to SimonCRMC)
>
> Ah, but that's only saying it's the best sgurr! ;-)

Gun tigeadh dhomhsa thar gach aite (My place above every other place)...?
;-)
JPSC - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Douglas Griffin:

> Though I agree, the Skye Cuillin in general is a place of superlatives.

I could not agree more, so I am going to disagree with everyone so far and nominate Sgurr na Stri for the simply amazing 360degree view. Over Loch Coruisk to the Cuillin Ridge to the west, round to the Red Cuillin and Bla Bheinn to the east and out over Loch Scavaig to Rum to the south.
Dave Perry - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia:

Try Ronas hill in the Shetlands. The tallest there and not much more than a 1000ft if I recall. It has a wide range of alpine flora and topographical features that aare associated with arctic conditions, and largely stands isolated from the surrounding countryside.

A splendid isolated climb if ever there was one and not one many of your 'experts' will have been up.
Fat Bumbly2 - on 11 Apr 2013
I am torn between Gillean and Boreray, but the abbing through guano bit probably edges it for Gillean.
newhey - on 11 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia:

Alias Craig is a cracking island. The summit is a sublime place to sit for an hour or two.
The Sgurr of Eigg is also a superb walk and a great place to end the night on.
fmck - on 12 Apr 2013
In reply to newhey:

More so spending a night on top of Ailsa Craig. That would be something. I'm going back on a RIB next month via lady isle just wish I could talk the rest of them into it.

Sgurr of Eigg we wanted to summit camp but was too misty/windy so opted for a beach camp burning dried out cow pats. Don't knock it I was surprised how long they burn for : )
ruttingstag on 12 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia: http://www.ukclimbing.com/images/dbpage.html?id=117129

the 360 degree view from here is pretty hard to beat.
Snoweider - on 12 Apr 2013
In reply to fmck:
> (In reply to Trangia)
>
> Cir Mhor. #1

Yep!
Dave Hewitt - on 12 Apr 2013
In reply to fmck:
> I'm going back on a RIB next month via lady isle

Lady Isle is an interesting place - great views and sense of space, but awkward to walk on due to a combination of holes and thick-stemmed grasses presumably helped along by the dead seabirds lying around all over the place. Re the Cuillin, I was much taken with Marsco.
Gordon Stainforth - on 12 Apr 2013
In reply to Dave Hewitt:

Yes, Marsco is an unspoken gem, a very impressive mountain indeed, with a very surprising knife-edge summit ridge. Not much frequented. Of course very much overshadowed by its much rockier and more dramatic Black Cuillin neighbours.
m dunn - on 13 Apr 2013
In reply to Trangia: Surprised no mention of Brandon Mountain ...
estivoautumnal - on 13 Apr 2013
In reply to Gordon Stainforth:

With a great little VS, The Snark.

This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.