/ Glen Nevis neglect.
Anyone know why some routes are so neglected in such an accessible area??
And has anyone done any of these routes in the last decade:
Caterpillar (very dirty from half-height)
Steerpike (tree too hollow to abseil, finish is abysmal)
Spring Fever (looked dirty)
Liquidator (choked with moss, unclimbably filthy)
Aquarian Rebels (thin sheen of lichen)
Chimera (looks filthy, and was a few years ago)
Easy Pickings (looks filthy)
Think Vertical (was bone dry but no sign of climbing)
Any other beta on where to avoid in the Glen??
Glen Nevis is mobbed with tourists in summer.
Because at it's best it's high quality outcrop climbing? Some people actually prefer outcrops, we're not all mountaineers...
Yes but he asked a question to why it is neglected and *I* gave my answer to why *I* personally neglect the crag. I like outcrops and cragging as much as the next guy, but I won't travel to the foot of The Ben to do it. Other people might have different answers, but the aggregation of them will answer his question.......
No idea, but even 15 years ago it was similar (possibly slightly better - certainly Liquidator & Aquarian Rebels were clean as a whistle 10 years ago...) - Car Park crag was always deserted despite Quality Street being a high quality route (as are the E2s up there who's names elude me at the moment but were very very good). Word tended to get around in town if the routes had had a clean and then they saw some traffic...
I currently don;t climb up there as I live 1500 miles away in a different country (lame excuse i know..).
Just a phrase. Nothing intended. I love cragging.
And there is your problem. Why not give it a clean-up yourself instead of avoiding it?
Pffft that is a lame excuse indeed.
Clearly the routes were given stars for good reason when they were put up, and most of the ones I mention are excellent lines up fine bits of rock. And I suspect that decades ago they did get climbed....but more so than today??
Okay changed my post...
Perhaps I should have been more specific - I'm interested in why some accessible **/*** classics seem completely neglected, whilst others are clearly well climbed. Obviously the easier routes throughout Polldubh get climbed, but I'm wondering why, for example, Edgehog is so bleached with chalk you can see it from the carpark, whilst routes of a comparable standard would take longer to wirebrush than they would to climb?? And whether the guidebook information / ratings should be considered at all accurate for anything other than the classics??
Because I'd rather drive 2.5 hours to go climbing, not cleaning.
I'm asking for information, not asking people to clean routes (although if locals did, that would be very welcome).
Well maybe this is a self perpetuating problem then? Now it started to get dirty/overgrown no one wants to clean it, so it gets more dirtier, and people dont want to clean it more, so it gets more dirtier... ?
Oh yeah, some of these routes will be doomed now, unless there is an concerted effort to clean them. What I want to know is why these routes have ended up in this state from their original **/*** status??
I've mentioned this on another thread but we used to carry brushes with us and clean *bits* of routes as we went. So rather than one person spending hours cleaning a route to the nth degree, the routes would become clean by many people climbing/attempting them and each cleaning just a little bit.
Obviously it means that everyone has to do their part and not just rely on someone else to do the graft for them.
Head down to your local hardware store and pick up a soft wire brush and make it part of your rack when climbing away from the honey pots.
Most likely the stars were based on the first ascentionist's write up, having just cleaned and climbed it. Routes climbed in the pre-internet age took years to get into a guidebook, and the number of locals operating at that grade and who knew of their existence probably wasn't sufficient to keep stuff clean, especially on shady north-facing crags.
I would have thought the string of shit summers (bar the last one in scotland so I hear) would have something to do with it.
> Oh yeah, some of these routes will be doomed now, unless there is an concerted effort to clean them. What I want to know is why these routes have ended up in this state from their original **/*** status??
.....because they probably need regular cleaning and the 'onsight obsessives' are not going to do this are they? You could have abbed down a few and cleaned them first.
That "E2" you did on Wave is given E3 in the SMC selective, though still with the "... high in the grade ..." description.
I'd agree with others who point to honey-potting towards the better-known and cleaner routes. This does seem to create a self-fulfilling prophecy whereby those routes stay clean but the others suffer.
Other factors are that some of the more distant buttresses take a fair bit of tick-infested jungle-bashing to reach, and that there is relatively little local traffic through the midgey summer months - on most evenings it's really not a good place to be! I also have a suspicion that the numbers of local climbers who are operating in the E-grades is much smaller than you would find at a crag nearer big cities.
> That "E2" you did on Wave is given E3 in the SMC selective, though still with the "... high in the grade ..." description.
This error has been noted before and is on the SMC web-site. "... high in the grade ..." should have been deleted. Apologies.
I think it's fair that the E3 stays. E3 5b??
Still at least that was well travelled, hell even the two terrible wire slots "protecting" the first 10m were quite well worn ;)
The Gorge and River Walls don't though, possibly the nicest walk of the buttresses there! And Wave isn't too bad by Scottish standards....there are great lines just in-between the well-worn Crackattack and Edgehog that shown no signs of climbing.
True, but conversely it's the *only* place to be in the spring / autumn months and really blowy weather when Coe and the other mountain areas would be out...
I've seen photos from about 20-30 years ago and the tree cover was a lot less. Not sure what changed this but the Polldubh Club deserve praise for having thinned it out on most of the more accessible buttresses on Polldubh.
It has to be said that Micah schist set amongst woodlands is always going to be prone to overgrowth - check out Glen Lednock sometime!
> Still at least that was well travelled, hell even the two terrible wire slots "protecting" the first 10m were quite well worn ;)
I've only seconded it but the three of us thought it was worth 5c. E3 5b is like a death grade (unless it's very sustained) and I think you'd survive.
> I've seen photos from about 20-30 years ago and the tree cover was a lot less. Not sure what changed this
Sheep were removed.
The entire Glen Nevis section of the SMC Scottish Rock Climbs guide is verbatim text from the section I wrote for the SMC Highland Outcrops guide. Only the errors are new! Some of the grades & star ratings were altered, but not the text; Ground Zero on Wave Buttress had grade changed from E2 5b (which I believe is correct) to E3 5c, but still retained the 'high in grade' description.
I was perplexed that I was never credited with this section, nor mentioned in the acknowledgements. Maybe the royalty cheque got lost in the post?
I know Jules Lines spent some time abseiling down & cleaning Aquarian Rebels last spring, so was definitely climbed last year. I've never understood the neglect of the routes in the glen - brilliant place to climb before the meejies arrive. Guess there's just not that many people interested in trad in Scotland, when they can get on the big numbers on the bolts...
That's probably right.
Sport climbing is the death of trad climbing in Scotland.
Unusually hot, still weather, chest high ferns, midgies and clegs- welcome to hillside cragging in mid summer. You'd be better going up to the actual mountain crags at this point in the season. You'll not get the Buachaille or other mtn crags drier...
I know that. It still doesn't account for the general neglect on the rare occasions that the Western Highlands don't have unusually hot, still, dry weather...
Lucky for you no one really cares what you think. I certainly don't.
> Lucky for you no one really cares what you think.
Is that right wee man, I'll bear that in mind next time I bump in to you. Just for the record, I'm actually held in quite high regard within and out with my peer group. What I suggest you do is stop top roping routes into submission before the lead and keep your stories of Ben Nevis hut records to yourself. BTW, did you ever get Jacobs Ladder done that day I bumped in to you? Fallout Corner was cracking. You should have come wae the big boys!
Haha. I've top roped a route three times, but that's neither here nor there.
I might not climb in the high grades like you Nigel, but I'd rather be having fun that climbing with some anti social climbers full of attitude that I wouldn't trust to hold my shopping never mind my ropes. I climb for myself and my friends, and if you don't fall into that group I simply don't care. End of.
It's a forum and I enjoy discussing things. That's the point. It's got nothing to do with you and neither has my climbing. You and your mates (although I suspect it's just you) creating aliases to wind up someone you don't even know just to get your jollies. I'm not scared of your veiled threats. Also I you pay attention your name is on the photos on your profile so I'm hardly divulging official secrets. Why don't you just do me a favour and feck off. I deleted you from Facebook for a reason. What I get up to is no concern to you.
Why not concern yourself with yourself rather than other people then! Do you not have better things to do with your life and family than get on at what other people post in their own time? What's it to you?
> Why not concern yourself with yourself rather than other people then! Do you not have better things to do with your life and family than get on at what other people post in their own time? What's it to you?
It's a public forum and I have an opinion, practice what you preach and stop worrying about others.besides giving advice about routes you've never done could be dangerous.
I refer you to my previous post of practicing what you preach.
As for problems, speak for yourself.
You took an olive branch and chucked it back. People skills, paranoia and wasting folks time in winter by not actually understanding the need for an early start and not letting folk down.
You actually thought I was responsible for previous posts telling you that you were a fan dan. Weird
nah, he's a clown....
Just cleaned and climbed Quality Street up at Car Park crag. Brilliant route. Now had 3 pairs of hands climb it today so is clean enough. Didn't clean the very bottom as I lost the feeling in my legs, but its easy. Also leaving the 1st belay I missed a section but again is ok. Great gear, great route. Perfect for these boiling hot days as it stays in the shade until 4.30ish. Hope it gets more ascents. To approach we walked to the head of the gorge and picked a nice path which traverses rightwards. We descended be going straight down the hill side. 60m rap from the top, in-situ ab station.
Good stuff, thanks. Will have to check it out soon then.
Milesy, Big Man, weegy, please be quiet.
I think people are less adventurous and also there are less climbers in the local area relative to the late nineties.
The countless bland blogs all writing about the same thing, in the same style also have not done much good.
Great place to go climbing though.
Elsewhere on the site
2012 saw the release of the beautiful first volume of definitive Yorkshire Gritstone climbing, produced by the YMC with Robin... Read more
The Women's Mountain Equipment Cho Oyu Jacket is the perfect choice for female mountaineers an explorers who... Read more
The Kendal Mountain Festival 2014 proved once again to be a busy and inspiring four days of films, photos, music, art... Read more
Backpackers want an extremely liveable and lightweight tent at good price. MSR answers the call with the Elixir 2 tent and... Read more
I am Matthew Phillips, I'm nearly 14 and I was born without my right arm below the elbow. I started climbing at taster... Read more