In reply to andi turner:
> (In reply to A Longleat Boulderer)
> [...]
>
> Whoa! Now I am confused! Every ascent until Ally, who I'm presuming to be the fourth ascentionist, it seems that the grade is just settling in to me.
> And it's 7c+ but a 7c+ climber would struggle to climb it?
This route has had God knows how many ascents (Cheddar 8's are pretty popular) each agreeing with 8a. This was right up until Ally found he pyhsically couldn't do the crux move the way we were doing it, so he he spent ages figuring out a new way to climb the top - I think he would have given up if I didn't keep wanting to go back to the route. Luckily on the day he did the crux, I was filming him, the next session he could not repeat the sequence for love nor money, so he went home to look at the footage of the previous session for the sequence and subsequently did the route with Dave Pickford (who used the same sequence).
Just for the record, I couldnt see how to do it even after watching the video! And for this reason, due to the extreme un-obviousness of the 7c+ sequence, I think it would stop almost all 7c+ climbers in their tracks. They would be try to go direct, this is the most obvious (and looks to be only) way to get to the top, and of course, any fule who has done the route knows, this was the original Pete Oxley method and is 8a. It would take them some considerable time to discover the 7c+ sequence - even then they might not. You really need to try the route before you can understand how hidden the sequence is. It has taken over a decade of ascents to discover.
> And the top move is now 6b, but feels 6c, which would make it the same as the original grade?
The top move with Ally's method is 6b in isolation, as the english grading system demands. But after climbing the start of the route, the move feels as if it could easily warrent 6c. Then you rest on the rope and try it again, and it feels piss... However, the direct way of doing the move feels hard whether in isolation or not.
Basically what I'm trying to say is, the route IS 7c+, but the majority (if not all) of future ascentionists are likely to miss the 7c+ sequence and use the original sequence which makes the route a grade harder.
Anyway, what does it matter? It is an awesome route, with a nice long-ish safe fall from the crux right at the top. GO AND GET ON IT!