In reply to Reach>Talent:
> It is not so much that the seal is bad, it still seems to be gas tight but that the thread won't pull the stove down far enough to push the valve open.
Ah, I was going to suggest that the thread isn't the thing responsible for a gas-tight seal; that'll be the rubber sealing washer. After four years of heavy use, it might need replacing.
Are you sure the problem isn't with the canisters you're using? I've seen reports of some canister needing a longer valve pin than is provided by some stoves; maybe worth googling before you start attacking your stove...