/ PRODUCT NEWS: VIDEO: The benefits of stainless steel crampons
Read more at http://www.ukclimbing.com/gear/news.php?id=2223
Not knowing much about metallurgy I'd be interested to hear an impartial viewpoint on both sides of the discussion.
SS has no advantage over CM steel other than looking nice and shiny in the shop.
I liked the bit with the laser cutting. No idea weather SS is any better mind.
they seem to make a point of saying stainless is lighter - so why is the entire range of black diamond crampons similar weight or heavier than the equivalent in the grivel range?
sounds like a load of marketing bs to me
I second that, have we got any materials scientists/engineers on UKC to shed light on any real benefits of Stainless crampons?
I have a 20yr old £rd class honours in metallurgy if that's any help (had a v.good time at uni). It is nothing too technical, tbh the grivel site explains it very well. BD crampons are stainless to attract the must buy shiny things crowd (the americans?)
Horse is a metallurgist, I believe.
I had read the grivel site but without other knowledge I wouldn't know who was telling the truth. I've already got 2 sets of crampons that barely ever get used so I can't see myself being drawn in to spending >£100 on a new pair no matter how shiny they are, even if this does relegate me to forever languishing in the world of punterdom.
Questions I'm asking myself now are;
How well do these hold their sharpness?
How often do they need sharpening in comparison to chromoly?
Will they go the way of the lightweight alloy crampons which end up as stumps after a few encounters with rock?
Does the metal bend easily? (like the frontpoints on my camp ice riders on which which one now elegantly points up and the other down and thats not from any seriously technical terrain)
Thats interesting - my Charly Poser non-stainess crampons don't seem to rust, I thought that was pretty surprising.
The cheap and nasty ones I had before did rust though...
Shiny Crampons wont get you out of punterdom, climbing does that. I nearly p*ssed myself at the green argument what with the plastic bails, straps and anti ball plates then the shipping, travel to advertise etc.
SS Crampons will work just as well as CM steel, like I posted earlier, shiny things.....
Any rust on ChromeMoly steel crampons is purely cosmetic dont worry
In relation to weight SS is weaker than cromolly!!!
This means that an SS crampon inevitably will be heavier than a cromolly crampon (of the same basic design) to have the same strength.
The SS crampon will be weaker but weigh the same.
If you like the bling-bling...
> Any rust on ChromeMoly steel crampons is purely cosmetic dont worry
No, that didn't worry me, it was the fact that they snapped that did!
He said it was lighter "by design". As others have said Cr-Mo steel will be stronger for a given weight. I can see no performance advantages in using this material.
I am as unbiased as your likely to get, I don´t have any ice climbing gear and don´t want any!
But I know loads about stainless and more than enough about chrome moly to give an opinion but it´s hard to give one at all when the manufacturers don´t tell us what they are using!
However note this is one company (Grivel) trying to rubbish at least two other companies products. We don´t know what BD are using for their crampons (well I don´t because my sound card is duff so if he said so anywhere in the video then tell me) but we do know what CAMP use for their crampons and ice tools, this is definately stainless steel and without a shadow of a doubt superior to the grades of chrome-moly used in the industry.
This is CAMP´s take on rubbishing Grivel!
Properties of traditional NI CR MO STEEL | Sandvik Nanoflex® is STRONGER | Sandvik Nanoflex® is HARDER | Sandvik Nanoflex® is STAINLESS | Sandvik Nanoflex® - MIRACLE METAL | Vector Nanotech | XLC Nanotech | Corsa Nanotech
The links are on their websites as well as the text in full, its too much for a cut and paste.
Personally I can´t see one of the biggest players in the business moving to an inferior product after making their reputation with high quality chrome molybdenum steel products, they aren´t that stupid!
Indeed but I am probably not going to be much use on this one for the simple reason BD don't say what the stainless steel is, either generically or specifically. The closest one can get to is on some comments on the BD site:
In which the the BD Crew say "We use a heat-treatable stainless in our crampons for excellent durability" which doesn't really help at all given there are hundreds of different steels that could fit the bill.
The Grivel stuff is a mixture of convenient, but misleading half truth, and knocking copy.
My best guess is that BD use some sort of precipitation hardened martensitic steel (sounds impressive eh!)with an optimum heat treatment for the end product. If this is the case then it could well have very good strength (as in tensile strength), high wear resistance (hardness) and be reasonably tough. Much better than CrMo steel probably not but might simplify manufacturing and/or reduce cost.
I also suspect that by "strength" BD don't really mean the tensile or yield strength of the steel but the overall strength of the component (crampon).
Brace yourself, incoming.
The Sandvik steel is a bit of an odd one (it seems to be semi stable austenitic/martensitic steel) that can be heat treated to give useful properties. The advantage seems to be that it can be heat treated at relatively low temperatures, interesting stuff.
However, given it has high Nickel and Molybdenum content it isn't going to be cheap so they will have save some weight to make it commercially viable.
They must spend a lot of money on R&D surely a move forward.
Well at least its got you talking about them!
Strange all those benefits are showed from Euro prices, not from US prices.
Old Cyborgs, 200 USD, made in China, 147-155 Euros.
New SS Cyborgs, 200 USD, made in China, 190 Euros (I'm referring roughly to Chamonix prices)
The USD-Euro exchange rate is sensibly lower today than in winter 2006-2007 (1 USD=0.75 Euros in november 2006, 1 USD=0,66 Euros november 2009).
Elsewhere on the site
Halifax-based John Colton (see his UKC Gallery here) has an art exhibition in Courmayeur, Italy (the Italian side of Mont Blanc)... Read more
2012 saw the release of the beautiful first volume of definitive Yorkshire Gritstone climbing, produced by the YMC with Robin... Read more
Over the years I've been asked many times about work as a Rope Access technician, often by Instructors and Guides working for... Read more
Make the most of this months HALF PRICE OFFER on the Five Ten Guide Tennie Mid!! Designed as a hybrid approach and... Read more
The Christmas Gift Guide at Outside.co.uk Check out our top selection of Christmas Gift Ideas for climbers,... Read more