/ NEWS: 8 Year Old Kids Cranking F8a and Font 8A
Over in the USA, 8 year old climber Ashima Shiraishi has climbed the classic V10/Font 7C+ Power of Silence at Hueco Tanks.
Read more at http://www.ukclimbing.com/news/item.php?id=52871
Anyone wanna buy a rack!?!
Awesome effort, makes you wonder what these kids might be capable of when they hit 16?!?
if your second name is "Traversa" does it give you an unfair advantage?
Ask Julie-Ann Clyma!
I used to solo the smaller cliffs around swanage when on holiday as a kid, there are now bolts & routes up some of them.
Real childhood experiences? not a huge amount different, except these nippers are doing routes hugely more difficult. I wish i'd had the opportunity...
Many kids do sport at highly intense levels, football, dance, gymnastics, martial arts, the list is long.
Though exploitation and projection are basically bad parenting/supervision.
Good luck to them! K
Exactly, he should be sat in his bedroom playing video games.
I agree with that. Climbing for very young kids has two main areas of concern:
- tight rockboots can and do result in hammer toes. I was read the riot act about this by my brother (a chiropodist) when I started taking my kids out. Actually I think very few people climb hard enough to justify painfully tight boots.
- harder routes often require a greater amount of small-edge crimping. This can be harmful to developing joints.
Set against that, joints like to be worked under load and the urge to climb is strong in many small kids - trees etc. However, the "holds" on trees tend to be open-handed (round branches) rather than crimped. I suppose it's all a question of degree and intensity.
Maybe their fingers are smaller therefore the holds are bigger therefore they don't require as much strength??
Just a theory.
If it is the case however i think we should start under 10 grading system!!!
Very very impressive! But the video seemed a little surreal.
How hard was Ondra climbing at 8?
Is there a president set regarding children climbing hard affecting their bone development? I wonder if there is a risk of lasting damage.
I work in engineering and young people are not allowed to use hammer action pneumatics because of bone development becoming inhibited of it's normal course.
Count me in... grown-up grading is just too hard
Yeah, I'm not a fan of that either. Still, I do wish I had the chance to start earlier, my parents were always supportive, never pushy but we just simply didn't have any climbers in the family.
not sure i agree but someone does seem to be projecting their love of Deep Purple via the website.
I don't think there is any suggestion of exploitation here, the parents don't seem to be living off the backs of their kids and they seem to be enjoying it. Plus, every man and his dog seems to have a website/blog.
Also, there is no suggestion that the kids are(over)training, it looks like they are being as active and energetic as most 8 year olds.
I think the uneasiness comes from seeing the very young doing exceptionally well (or better) at a sport that at lot of older folks have dedicated their life too. Based on this thread it seems that this uneasiness is particularly strong in men
How do you know that the kids haven't been over-training ?. I wouldn't have thought that this level of climbing comes from just natural ability, and a laissez-faire attitude parents usually have to the amount of time children want to spend at an activity. Presumably there would have been a lot of intensive training - just as young gymnasts mentioned above, swimmers etc. Does Dad ? shouting in the background sort of suggest that, or was it just typical American enthusiasm ?
There is no uneasiness on account of my lack of ability/dedication, but i will show the video to my eight year old daughter and tell her to buck her ideas up when next down the climbing wall.
> There is no uneasiness on account of my lack of ability/dedication, but i will show the video to my eight year old daughter and tell her to buck her ideas up when next down the climbing wall.
I think I'll do the same. The lazy wee besom is clearly not trying hard enough :o)
I said there was 'no suggestion of over training' (of course 'training' and 'over training' are not concrete terms). Perhaps you could find some evidence rather than just speculating?
They obviously climb a lot, but as mentioned before 8 year old's are (and should be) pretty energetic: I guess its just a matter of where that energy is directed (by themselves, friends, and parents etc).
Climbers starting young is not a new thing, I remember reading about Tommy Caldwell belaying his dad on some long and tough trad lines at a young age. I am sure there are many more historical examples. Perhaps what has changed is the focus on sports climbing and grades.
Someone just had to say it didn't they, way to ruin a sensible discussion. Nobody wants to piss on the kids bonfires, I just hope we don't end up like gymnastics, embroilled in scandal over the explotation of young atheletes. The physical peak of female atheletes for pure strength to weight activities is around the point of adolescence, hence the low retirement age of female gymnasts. In order to exploit that peak, coaches pushed harder and harder younger and younger and many female gymnasts as a result retire with an enourmous catalogue of injuries that will be with them for the rest of their lives. Particularly disturbing is how the natural progression of puberty is disturbed.
Now, I climb at the Westway a lot and they actually take a very sensible approach (they have a lot of youngish and very talented girls on their squad). The youngsters boulder only once a month (or something similarly infrequent) and there is no specific training, just lots of climbing. And that's healthy, for sure. But these girls are operating at maybe high 6s to low 7s. I just worry that v10 and 8a are not natural for 8 year olds because they require exceptional finger strength. However, if these kids can genuinley just climb a couple of times a week for fun and go on to climb that hard, more power to them. I just don't want to see a culture of exploitation of young atheletes develop like was prevelant in gymnastics until the rule changes.
And Jody, how many 8 year olds do you know who made their own professional website? I'm sorry, I refuse to buy that.
I am totally against young kids training to point that negatively affects their physical and/or mental health. However, I thought it was interesting how the intial thread responses seemed to assume or worry that the kids were being over-trained (i.e. expiolated) based only on the high grades they were achieving and the fact that one of the kids had a website.
"if these kids can genuinley just climb a couple of times a week for fun and go on to climb that hard, more power to them"
Can they not have fun climbing more than just a couple of times week?
"made their own professional website?"
I didnt see the site asking for money, so what is professional? He is obviously climbing well as has a website promoting the fact. Even if the website's aim is attract free gear from sponsors I dont see anything wrong (or professional) with that.
Elsewhere on the site
Pete Whittaker has flashed the 32 pitch route Freerider 5.12d on El Capitan in Yosemite Valley over three days,... Read more
The Grivel A&D Ascender & Descender is brand new for Autumn 2014 and incorporates a revolutionary and innovative patented... Read more
This survey is being conducted by the Outdoor Industries Association in order to find out more about how and why people... Read more
Nuts, wires, stoppers, chocks, wedges, whatever you want to call them, have been around for a long time. Initially made from... Read more
From a personal point of view, photographing the night sky is one of the most difficult, frustrating yet ultimately rewarding... Read more