Also interested in thoughts on the top pitch itself ie. Brothers Direct.
I always thought it was soft at E1, more like HVS really. Doing it again, I thought the gear under the small overhang prior to the crux was not as good as I'd remembered though ok enough if you don't mind spending some time fiddling in wires. The small thorn tree which greeted you on pulling up on the rounded holds also appears to have gone. Oddly, this seems to have made it easier as it used to guard (in a pricklish way) some of the better handholds on the LHS. With the slightly easier finishing holds exposed on the LHS, I'd just give it HVS now I think.