In reply to Ramon Marin:
[Apologies for picking your post to reply to - I'm just playing devil's advocate here!
And I realise that this specific crag is a bad example, as it seems like it was developed by a local guy purely as a dry tooling/mixed climbing venue]
BUT I'm just trying to understand the justifications.
> they are probably wet in summer, so those routes would never be rock climbs anyway.
Kilnsey is normally wet in summer
and winter but I suspect people might be a bit upset if this were the excuse they used to start dry tooling there if a little patch of ice formed.
> For those in the dark, those routes are probably impossible to rock climb, just check the 2mm hook he's using.
Surely sport routes at the cutting edge are blanker than dry tooling routes, with far smaller holds? I've never been dry tooling or mixed climbing in my life, so excuse my ignorance, but I imagine it'd be harder to dry tool something like Golpe Estado, Jumbo Love, Biographie or any of the F9a+ routes at Santa Linya than to sport climb them? But then I have no idea. Purely speculating.