In reply to shingsowa: No, not really
> (In reply to IainRUK)> Plas y Brenin - Great guys, an institution, they are practically giving you the training out of the kindness of their souls and only require a small fee...
Plas y Brenin, Glenmore Lodge, Tollymore are national centres, where they not only provide the lower level courses, SPA/ML/ etc, they provide the higher ones that are for want of a better phrases only taught by those instructors who are most current with that syllabus. They might not be any better instructors, but what they are is very current and very good at teaching people how to teach others etc.. This applies to other sports, not just the mountain ones. In with the package you get food and accomm.
> 'Commercial' Instructors - Money grabbing barstewards, how dare they ask for money to provide a service?
As well as providing lower level quals, they also provide instruction to a clients needs, that probably won't match any of the centres course programme. They could be target specific weakness in relation to a qualification or just being taken down some quality rivers or up some great rock. You might need to organise all your own accommodation and food, others will assist.
It's horses for courses, the individual has to work out his needs and do what best suits them. There are variables as national centres also provide courses just for experience or skills, but I see their most important function as principly developing future qualified instructors, not just the leadership quals.