In reply to Conan: Rob Dyer the BMC national access officer and myself have spent several hours at Foredale this morning talking to the farmer, his family and several residents of Foredale Cottages.
There are several issues which we could not resolve and to be fair we had much sympathy for many of the concerns expressed. In general one of the main problems is simply that Foredale has become a victim of its own success and the visitor numbers, particularly on fine weekends and summer evenings have become a grave irritation to the local residents. That could perhaps be eased by negotiating a different access route but – see below – would it work?
A more specific problem for the residents of the cottages is that despite all our clearly positioned BMC notices directing climbers where to park and walk some are still driving and/or walking up to and through the residents private parking area. On top of that it is claimed some have become abusive and rude when challenged and were seen kicking down the residents own notice board. I really find it impossible to defend such behaviour and if the offenders can be identified they should be vilified by us all. They cannot possibly have any excuse!
Another concern of the residents is regarding the lack of toilet facilities at the crag and worries that their water supply may become polluted. One climber has been seen urinating close to the water supply pipe source.
Mr Pearson himself has several concerns regarding damage to walls and fences and gates being left open (he initially agreed to us, in conjunction with the YDNPA, providing new gates and stiles but he has since rescinded this idea). He also believes that climbers are still taking dogs to the crag?
His major concern most recently, however, is that he has discovered that a local climbing wall has been offering a series of guided courses at Foredale at £90 per head. (Rob will speak to the wall concerned about this).
The bottom line is that whilst Moughton Nab and its approaches are on Access Land Mr Pearson doesn’t accept this gives a right to climb and confrontation on this point at this stage would be counter-productive. The current access route to Foredale is clearly across Mr Pearson’s Land and he has every right to restrict access that way as he sees fit.
Our consultations and negotiations will continue but in the mean-time please avoid any further confrontation.
P.S. Please remember that any responses you make to this post will be read by the residents and Mr Pearson. Please keep any comment constructive.
Dave