In reply to phleppy: Only E4? E4's can be extremely hard and it's probably closer to E6... Voila 3, Summo Cellulite, both E4, lower tier, I'd be extremely surprised if they'd been repeated. Or Sidewinder or Steps or Gillted...I cleaned then climbed Punch a few weeks back, I'd be amazed if that had been climbed in the last 15 years, again a starred route on one of the most popular crags in the country and "only" E4
Yes, there are some 'dark horses' who secretly tick off test pieces, but a lot less than you'd imagine.
Pete is a superb climber, but I know he has had to put a lot of effort into climbing this route. Even routes like Secrets of Dance, Licence to Lust, Drop Acid, and Slips have at most had a handful of ascents. It'd be great to think that all routes get their fair share of ascents, but people tend to stick to the same old ones time and again.
I'd put £10 down that Pete's is the second ascent.