In reply to UKC:
Re. Halldrine routes.
The longstanding local policy at Halldrine has been to record defined routes and to leave the rest as a go-as-you-please playground.
Routes that are 'officially' recorded are Limpet Slab (M Hardy, R G Pettigrew, 28.7.56), Inverted V-Groove and Geological Groove (Commando Cliff Assault Wing, 1956).
Shrimpet and Barnaclet were climbed and named as defined lines by myself and Roger Mitchell in 1986. I climbed, with Roger and various partners in later years, what have been subsequently named as The Love Wagon Rides Again, Slow Worm, Dolphin Song, Osteopath Wall, Drop Out and a crag-wide spread of alternatives.
Ours were not the first footfalls on the Moon, by any means.
The Climbers' Club early 1990s guides recorded Shrimpet and Barnaclet to add some variety to the crag. I chose not to record our names to first ascent claims, due to the general assumption that for many years the CCAW, many local climbers, including the venerable Dennis Bateman, and visiting climbers had wandered at will all over this splendid little crag. The conventional wisdom in those days was that the entire South West telephone directory had blanketed the crag with lines and alternatives.
This in no way negates the good efforts of subsequent climbers who have every right to 'pioneer' what they honestly believe to be unclimbed or unrecorded lines. The fault lies with the equally honest tradition of leaving small crags that have a majority of climbable lines at the same low grades to be 're-discovered'.
The flaw in this last policy is now obvious. Times change, and it is fair to say that new generations of climbers, understandably, wish to record and claim lines that they believe have not been climbed/recorded.
The forthcoming Climbers' Club guides to West Cornwall will clarify the situation at Halldrine. Innocent retrospective claims may well be recorded but perhaps with some kind of rider - 'First claimed by...' or 'May have been climbed before...' I stress that an agreed policy on dealing with these kinds of situations has not yet been decided.
On the other hand we may just note; First Ascent - C. R. O. Magnon, Circa 41,000BC; retro-claimed by Uther Pendragon & Son, 6th century.
None of this detracts from the admirable efforts of those contributing to this thread and those who have done sterling work on recording and publicising routes at Halldrine in good faith and with enthusiasm.
PS Shrimpet is entirely independent of Inverted V-groove and is a neat little gambol - so there!
Des Hannigan