/ Mammut Smart Vs Climbing wall attendants
The following is the official handling guide for a smart and as you can see you are meant to touch the device allot compared to an ATC style device: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A684wbremic
That video puts the nerves up me. I know it's a different type of device, but I don't like the idea of slowly sliding the dead rope through my hand to pay out on any device, and I definitely don't like the way they slide their hand through on taking in.
I can see why someone in a position of responsibility not used to the device would pull someone up on it.
Indeed, if that's the only practical way to use one, rather than treating it as an ATC with a better grabbing/locking capability, I won't be bothering with one. But by the look of the device it seems it could be used like an ATC if you wanted - you seem to think that's not practical, out of interest why not?
 I know you have to on any device to some extent, but even when using a Grigri I'll do it the same way as I do on an ATC - slide dead rope hand down as quickly as possible then move your hand up to the device with a loop of rope held tightly, pay out through the device and repeat. That "slow slide" is a point at which loss of control is more of a possibility, IYSWIM.
It looks absolutely fine to me, although I have to say i'm not familiar with the device.
If I'm abseiling on a doubled, thickish rope I'll often tilt my belay device (currently a Reverso) a bit with my spare hand to smooth the feed out.
I'll also briefly pull the device away from the krab with my spare hand as part of the initial movement of paying rope out.
All perfectly normal and IMHO they're making a fuss out of nothing. A little knowledge etc
"It looks absolutely fine to me, although I have to say i'm not familiar with the device."
That's probably the issue - it doesn't necessarily look like a locking device, more like an oddly shaped ATC type device, and the movements in that video on taking in would *definitely not* be OK with a non-locking device, and less safe than the alternatives on paying out.
Perhaps the best solution is to talk to the wall manager and suggest they train their staff on them?
"Don't you have to touch a GriGri too to give slack for clipping?"
Yes, you have to use the lever or top of the cam.
I'm going to try using it again tomorrow and depending on the reaction I'll either keep using it or order a GriGri..
You only need to touch a gri gri if you yank the rope and activate the cam.
Although it's not consider bad practice to keep it closed, if you retain control of the dead rope.
My climbing partner uses one, they are really very good, but you cannot pay out without lifting the device.
Every now and then I use it. At the end of the climb I try and pay out as usual (reverso) but nothing happens leaving me confused until I remember I'm using the smart.
I think a short demo to the wall supervisor should sort out any problems
i use a smart at the climbing wall all the time when i am belaying someone on top rope.
i hesitated for a long time to use it for belaying a leader... but after some practice, with the leader on easy stuff where short roping him when hes about to clip wasnt going to be a huge concern, i am now comfortable with the device.
i climbed a multi pitch with someone who was using an alpine smart... after seeing that in action, my next belay device will be an alpine smart.
i see no reason why i wouldnt want to have that extra bit of security.
it is a bit "grabby" when lowering someone, especially someone heavier than me, as you try to find that perfect amount of pressure on the lever so the rope runs through smoothly
I really like how easy it is to pay out slack for the leader using it the official way: I had been made to pay out like it was a ATC in the past which was very frustrating as the device grabs to easily for that to work well.
Elsewhere on the site
2014 has been a bumper year for climbing publications. Here's a few of the ones that we have either read, or ones that we... Read more
Hot Aches Productions premiered their latest film Redemption: The James Pearson Story at Kendal Mountain Festival on... Read more
On the run up to Christmas we have some great savings on all your favourite brands, so its the perfect time to do the... Read more
WINTERFEST 2014 at Outside in Hathersage 6th and 7th December 2014 Outside's ever popular Winterfest event is back... Read more
If asked to name a British female climber who stood out at a time when British women's climbing wasn't... Read more