/ Maths Question : Complex Numbers
The solution(s) to x^2 -4 = 0 shows you where the curve f(x) = x^2 -4 crosses the x-axis (+2 & -2).
The curve f(x) = x^2 +4 does not cross the x-axis and the solutions to x^2 + 4 = 0 are complex (+2i & -2i).
What does this represent graphically?
you can draw them on an argand diagram but not on a normal xy axis
Basically the same thing, except than rather than a function that takes the real number line (the x axis) to another real number line (the y axis), f(x) is being thought of as a function that takes a complex plane to another complex plane, which is a bit harder to visualize because it's four dimensional.
> ...which is a bit harder to visualize because it's four dimensional.
I wondered why I was having trouble.
One way of handling it is:
draw a (merely 3d) graph where the x and y axes are the complex plane and the z axis is the real part of f(x+iy)
do the same for the imaginary part of f(x+iy)
each of these has a line in the plane z = 0 where the graph crosses it. This represents the points in the complex plane for which the real and imaginary parts respectively of f(x+iy) are zero.
Draw these two lines on the same plane. f(z) = 0 at the points where they meet.
Often people seem to visualize complex valued functions by looking at a 3d graph of the absolute value, which can help a bit...
I think that s the sort of image I was after, though I am going to have to work at it to visualise what is going on.
As y reduces towards 2, the bottom of the bowl reduces in minimum height, until it reaches 0 (at y=2), then bounces up again to peak at 4 (y=0), before reducing again to reach 0 at y=-2, then bounces up again and gets further away from the ground again.
Alternatively, think of a conventional bowl, touching the ground at the point (0,0). Do a sort of upward karate chop at this point, leaving the bowl touching the ground at (0,2) and (0,-2) with an upward wave-like curve where it used to touch the ground!
How do you all know this shit? Very impressive!
> How do you all know this shit? Very impressive!
Don't worry mate, they're just making it up.
I really would appreciate a picture of this. You are describing something that I can't easily see. More work required on my part, I guess.
I don't know this, that's why I am asking grown ups.
THIS THREAD was started in off belay and should have been started in Gobbeldygook, Please try to post in the correct forums etc.
One nice thing is that for the quadratic funtion f(z)= (z-a)^2 +b (a,b real), which, for real z, has a graph which is a parabola with minimum f(z)=b at x=a, takes real values for values of z on the real axis and on a line parallel to the imaginary axis through z=a. A graph of these real values plotted perpendicular to the complex plane consists of the original parabola and another one in a plane perpendicular to the original parabola with a max f(z)=b at z=a. ie "upside down", rotated 90 degrees around its axis of symmetry, and touching the original parabola at its minimum point. For your funtion with a=0 and b=4, this second parabola cuts the complex plane at 2i and -2i.
I don't think I've made that very clear, but it is late...
> I really would appreciate a picture of this. You are describing something that I can't easily see. More work required on my part, I guess.
I think it is like an arse sitting on the complex plane with the arse crack running above and parallel to the real axis with the anus directly over the origin. The arse makes contact with the complex plane at +2i and -2i. Assume a very firm, pert arse that doesn't squash at all on contact. Think Kylie. That's how I'm picturing it anyway. I hope this helps.
SQRT(x^4 + y^4 + 2x^2y^2 + 8(x^2 - y^2) + 16)
Then choose a 3D surface graph of this. However, as the bit you want to see is at the bottom, it's hidden, so I changed the formula to -SQRT, so that Kylie is on her front with her bottom nicely in the air!
Will email you the excel file.
Pero and Robert Durran,
Thanks. No surprise but I can easily visualise a bum.
Each aesthetic in their own way....
> THIS THREAD was started in off belay and should have been started in Gobbeldygook, Please try to post in the correct forums etc.
Currently old folks (like me) say that the 'young uns' these days just type a question into a smartphone (used to be a scientific calculator) and the answer comes up (probably on a video in U-Tube.)
Is this just lies that I have been puting around?
Elsewhere on the site
The Epicentre Mega Winter Sale starts in store 9am Christmas Eve. We have a great selection of in store only deals from... Read more
This years ROCfest will be slightly different. We've decided to run a Climbing Festival, not just a competition! Over... Read more
F ounded in 1993, Mountain Hardwear are a pretty young mountaineering clothing and equipment manufacturer but are also one of... Read more
On Saturday 13th December Greg Boswell and Guy Robertson kicked off their Scottish winter season early by making the... Read more
At a bar in Llanberis an old man chimed in And I thought he was out of his head Being a young man I just laughed it off When... Read more