In reply to Sonya Mc:
> routes only up to 7a won't be much use for a dedicated sport climber.
You people have rather perculiar definitions of what a dedicated sport climber is. I would have assumed it would be more about the dedication, i.e. the inspiration and passion for sport climbing, rather than about a grade.
I think it's great that the SMC are working on a full definitive sport guide, and that Andy (who may or may not be a dedicated sport climber!) took over and focused on getting the job done - however the 7aMax guide should be out first, and will be useful at a time of year when trad climbing is pretty arduous.
As awkward as it might be for the SMC, guidebook competition is likely to be a good thing - having witnessed the effect of Rockfax in the Peak District, encouraging the BMC to up their guidebook game to a world-class level (admittedly it is probably somewhat harder in the wet, disparate, and insular arena of Scottish climbing!)