In reply to Fickalli:
> (In reply to Timmd)
>
> Yeah I got that and my reply was light hearted too. However, I don't know why we have so many of these analysis threads on UKC. Are climbers more green? Are we cleverer than everyone else? Do we have better jobs? Are we more creative? Are we more inward looking? It's pretty self indulgent!
Here's a bit of analysis to explain why we have so much analysis on UKC
People posting on here lie in the overlap of the venn diagram: 'likes rock climbing'; 'likes posting on internet forums'. I think rock climbing dos attract a fairly wide range of people, but trad climbing in particular I think is skewed towards introverts (just from experience of the people I know who are passionate trad climbers...and I'm not talking hugely introverted, just a bit that way; after all they like spending hours completely cut off from the rest of reality looking just at the holds and gear, questioning whether they are capable of overcoming the obstacle knowing that no one else can help them other than by shouting "hurry up, you've been up there hours" from the belay ledge below). Introverts are more likely to think a lot about their lot in life, are they satisfied with their work/climbing/relationships/life, and posting on the internet is a way to express that without having to be overly social.
People who post on internet forums are obviously nerdy. That goes without saying, but to add a bit more colour, of the Myers-Briggs types, it's the analytical/judgemental/introverted ones (e.g. INTJ) that you'll find getting into arguments on the internet. You see, they're helping all the stupid people who for some reason bother to express their worthless, pointless, misguided opinions on matters such as religion and politics, to understand the world properly. Discussion of ideas, particularly, why good ideas are right, and why crap ideas are wrong, is a favourite hobby of this type of person and internet forums provide a perfect way to pursue it.
I don't think that people who post in The Pub and Off Belay are representative of climbers, but they're very representative of people who post on internet forums, which is a far more personality-correlated activity. People that post about gear and stuff are just nerdy, without the judgemental/argumentative characteristics you get in the non-climbing stuff.
And if you don't agree with my analysis, then you're probably one of the stupid people (maybe you're a Tory and Christian too?) in which case, I've tried to help, but there's only so much you can do.
NB. If you take this post seriously, please don't post anything in response. If you do, I will bang my head against the keyboard repeatedly until my skull caves in. That won't be nice for the next user of this computer.