/ Moments Question Physics/Maths/engineering?
There is uniform rod of weight W, leaning at an angle a from the vertical. It is fixed at the top and at the bottom.
Resolving W perpendicularly (p) and parallel (||) to the rod,
Wp = Wsin(a), W|| = Wcos(a)
Take moments about the bottom, then I get a force at the top acting perpendicularly to the rod of W/2 . sin(a).
Similary taking moments about the top, I get a force acting perpendicularly at the bottom, of W/2 . sin(a).
The || components at top and bottom at W/2 . cos(a).
Resolving vertically at the top & bottom, I get
Ftopv = W/2 . sin(a). sin(a) + W/2 . cos(a) .cos (a) = W/2
And the same for the bottom, which both add up neatly to W, as expected.
When I look at the horizontal components, I don't get a neat answer.
What should I get?
All you can say about the components parallel to the rod at the top and they total Wcos(a) (The component of the rod's weight parallel to the rod). Their combined horizontal component is then Wcos(a)sin(a), which balances the combined horizontal components of your perpendicular components at each end.
I get those terms, but the signs are the same, so I can't get them to cancel out as I think they should.
(and the same at the other end)
Surely, the horizontal force at the top is non-zero and of opposite sign to that at the bottom?
That would imply the rod was under net tension or compression... I see no reason for that to be the case.
I think I was getting confused with 'ladder leaning against rough wall' type problems. Thanks.
Elsewhere on the site
Manchester Climbing Centre are showing Brit Rock on Thursday the 27th of November at 7pm. Homegrown adventure comes... Read more
Every so often you meet someone in climbing that makes you take a step back. Someone with a fire in their eye, passion in... Read more
The Grivel A&D Ascender & Descender is brand new for Autumn 2014 and incorporates a revolutionary and innovative patented... Read more
Nuts, wires, stoppers, chocks, wedges, whatever you want to call them, have been around for a long time. Initially made from... Read more
This week's Friday Night Video is an interview with Mina-Leslie Wujastyk filmed by Nick Brown. On 14th October 2014, Mina... Read more