In reply to Henry Iddon:
I'm not sure that the argument really holds. I do happen to think that these type of awards in general are extremely silly, but even so, I'm saying something different about the Turner Prize.
The BAFTAs (I'm guessing, so correct me if I'm wrong) give awards to successful television that the public watch and understand and even love. People like to see their favourite shows winning awards in a glitzy ceremony full of 'celebs' wearing fancy outfits - I'm guessing. It might be pointless and crap, but there is no dishonesty of sham particularly, it's just rubbish and pointless. And mountaineering isn't about having an audience, and it doesn't have one apart from mountaineers, so I don't think it's comparable or relevant.
If the Turner Prize was just an art prize for the art world that I, like the man in the green pullover, don't understand, then it wouldn't rub me up the wrong way. However, it is elevated to something more than that, by the celebrity presenters (who I believe are 'going along with it' - we know Madonna was because of the Mr Brainwash thing), the Channel 4 coverage, etc. So there is a pretense around it that those outside the 'inner circle' get it, when they don't. For the art world, it's quite serious I'm sure. But it has gathered a wider audience who, I believe, don't know what's going on, but pretend to. And it makes money and carries kudos - advertisers are interested...who's going to stop it now?