In reply to UKC Gear:
sea to summits bags indeed are a layer of primaloft type stuff laid over down. to my mind a good theory, but one that S2S dont apply fully enough - the prima will give a good degree of protection from external moisture, but not enough to make a big enough diference internally as it doesnt quite trap enough air.
prima in a triple layer has a hydrostatic head of about 12,000 (similar to neoshell) so has good effects there, but then becomes a barrier that can allow condensation if the warmth it contains isnt enough to keep the moist air fine enough to pass thru.
i am not convincedthe S"S version has the down-synth ratio right; but then the tests ive been involved with have used primaloft, whereas S2S use something else.
regarding spacer textiles (really to good to see mr fullers points here); alpha is quite different to earlier versions - the hype is mostly deserved if not for concept, then for technology.
earlier versions have been either meshes, high loft piles, 3d meshs as per mr fullers image, or netting with different weaves (something nordic companies have been big on for decades).
alpha tho is a 3d knit that combines a knitted structure with clusters of randomly structured 'fluff' that approximate down and is similar to thermoball (another insulation story for another time).
its very cool stuff in that the weight-thermo efficiency is greater than other knits of the same thickness and far far better than a 3d mesh (that has 2 facing layers).
alpha also has a stretch element.
where this applies to sleeping systems (having done 5 months of tests with different alpha variations) is that alpha is simply efficient at allowing heat transfer from the body to the sleeping bags insulation (which if down, drys it out, and if then covered in a synthetic layer, pushes moisturre out to where its less compromising). primaloft doesnt do this, trapping too much heat against the body. it feels similar at first, but the bag isnt getting enough heat into it to push the mositure away.
its efficient also in that an alpha layer works then well both as an active layer and as a sleeping/static layer; multifunctional. it dries so fast (3 times faster than primaloft) that it sort of works as a wicking fibre.
even better is it doesnt require the sort f fibre-proof fabrics around it that prmaloft and down do, so can be encased in meshes.
dedicated alpha inner bags im not sure are that useful, as simply wearing alpha clothing will work as well. maybe a bag for the lower half, or if its very cold then alpha insulated trousers. alpha breathes well enough as an active garment (tho dependant on whats been used to face it) that garmenst in it have a much greater functioning temp range than prima.
as a part of a super-cold system where alpha garments are being worn a lot of the time anyway, combined with -30c rated s/bags its easy to see the benefits.
all said, prima is still definitely in the game as a moisture limiting textile, and if companies dont optimize on the difference between the two textiles then both will see problems.