/ What should be avoided in a climbing vid.
I think this one has a few examples http://www.vimeo.com/51930029#
Slow motion, no idea of scale, odd choice of filter, talking rather than climbing.
As most bouldering videos are tedious in the extreme I would suggest the following.
Avoid filming it altogether.
However, if you persist. Avoid using just one camera. Avoid a grungy metal soundtrack. Avoid using male only climbers. Avoid non HD filming. Avoid a cheap editing package.
So bouldering videos are tedious? More tedious than videos of trad/sport climbs?
That recent video of Mina L-W doing Careless Torque was excellent - the right mix of action and talking (with a genuinely charismatic person in front of the camera), the climb filmed so that you could see the moves in context but also see how much of a struggle it was for the climber, edited well so that it had a real flow to it and was continually interesting.
I'm not a fan of videos that just show send after send, especially if the problems are not particularly well known. I find it much more interesting to see, even if its just a snippet, the process of failure and then success. Unless of course its a flash!
I don't really mind slow-mo, talking or fancy filters if used sparingly and the problems are portrayed effectively to give you a good sense of scale and difficulty.
I have some sympathy with estivoautumnal's view, but I'd also say that editing together lots of clips of people falling off the same holds over and over again to show how hard a problem is really cranks up the bore-ometer. I know that's what bouldering is, but it's not very watchable.
Also, with the soundtrack, I'd try to avoid stuff that attempts to give the impression of great drama; whether that's fast metal (really, no), drum'n'bass or something that has an 'epic' or 'moving' feel to it, I find it a bit embarrassing when the climbing is just falling two feet onto a pad - it's not dramatic.
There are some bouldering videos that I like. Either exciting highball stuff (pro's) or classic problems being climbed well (not fallen off) shot nicely with some good tunes on.
Film of the drive there (especially 'arty' reflection shot in wing mirror
Intrusive sound track
I've seen worse than the one the OP linked to. In fact, I've seen a LOT worse videos than that.
I'll agree about the shots lasting more than a few seconds.
There was the video with one of the wide boys climbing a route with approach shoes, it was schizophrenic.
Surely I can do well with just some good content and basic editing. Maybe it sounds like i'm just moaning. I'll make something and share my tender creation with the wise people of the ukc forums.
That ones pretty rubbish because it doesn't show much. Whereas the ones on the Underdeveloped extras are really good - action, humour, plenty of problems, failure, success, good music that I've never heard before...
Generally though, it has to be hard to be interesting.
Dont obliterate the camera sound track with overbearing music.
If you can make it work without music then you have made a good video.
> Single camera angles, and single shots lasting more than maybe 5-10 seconds.
> For something a little different, I lifted this link from the other channel as an example of what you can do:
Maintain a sense of fun - the above video at least contained some people enjoying themselves and the video. Avoid the too much coverage of 'intense young men'.
I'd avoid being misanthropic if I were you.
That Don Willans/ Joe Brown Cemetary Gates video that was on the front page a couple of weeks ago is my favourite ever climbing video. Managed to hold me in rapt attention for the entire half hour or so.
I guess it depends what type of climbing is being done. For multipitch trad, the situation is often impressive enough that you don't need to do anything fancy with it.
Elsewhere on the site
Climbing as a discipline offers plentiful metaphors for tackling life's obstacles - bravery, courage, climbing to... Read more
On Sunday 12th October the Depot Climbing Centre Leeds held its 5th annual Battle of Britain competition. The competition has... Read more
Aiming at designing and producing the best belay glasses to protect climbers’ necks, Y&Y focuses on every detail to... Read more
Pete Whittaker has flashed the 32 pitch route Freerider 5.12d on El Capitan in Yosemite Valley over three days,... Read more