In reply to Fraser:
> (In reply to mark20)
>
> It could also be corrosion on the wheel itself, which is compromising the tyre seal.... £5 well spent in any Kwik-Fit type place.
Often times my daughter's have taken a tyre problem to 'similar establishments' they have told them the tyre was: 'beyond repair' or 'dangerous' and tried to sell them a new tyre.
I then take it to a local garage I can trust , and inevitably they just fix it with no comment! ((maybe we are just unlucky)
I would always get second opinion if that happens .
So don't turn up with the tyre ON the car, take the wheel off yourself, so you can just throw it back in your boot and get a second opinion.
If your car is up on their ramp your options are much more limited to argue, so YOU want to be in control, put on your spare and give them the dodgy wheel only, you can then just drive off to check out their opinion.
If the second opinion then says the same thing, you can still then drive off and take time shop around for the best deal, and so you do not just have to be rushed into buying whatever tyre they have in stock, when they don't have to give you a competitive quote whilst your car is up on their ramp.