/ Rab Boreas or Buffalo Wind Shirt
Rab Cirrus – large is too baggy but medium is too tight.
Marmot – same as Rab.
Montane Featherlite – sleeves too short, only xl has long enough sleeves for me, but is huge everywhere else
Patagonia Houdini – I like Patagonia gear, but 80 odd quid for a wind top is a bit much
North Face Flyweight – good hood and shape but body length too short
Paramo ‘Tattie Sack’ Fuera – fit is horrible also too heavy and not as packable as the rest.
My body shape/size is obviously a problem, I’m 6’1, slim-ish build, slighty disproportionate upper-upper body and a longer than average arm length (ideal for climbing but crap for fitting clothes).
I’m thinking about looking at the Buffalo Wind Shirt, and also considering the Rab Boreas, any opinions on either of these? What is the sizing like on them? Any other suggestions for a breathable, lightweight, packable wind top?
With regards to fit, Buffalo size their 'upper' garments in 2 inch increments, starting from about 34/36 inches to around 46 inches. As such, you should be able to find a good fit depending upon what you wear underneath at any given time.
Boreas and Buffalo were both too short in the body for me (6'2"). Marmot Ether was a lot better but not purely a windshirt.
I'm a bit the same re:fit but I found the Boreas too baggy around the waist and a tad tight across the back and shoulders (in an XL) though the arm length is good. It's a useful bit of gear, I found it very good for trekking at altitude in Peru a couple of years back and good for cool weather rock climbing. It's also a tad more urban than a Buffalo shirt so you can wear it around towns etc a bit more stylishly, so good for travel and better value in the long run. Not as rain-resistant as a Buffalo though.
I've also owned or tried the Houdini, Fuera and Marmot. I've got several Arcteryx Squamish tops which I find better than all those but they are expensive unless you get them on sale (rare). They're like a Houdini, with a better fit.
The Norrona Bitihorn Aero 60 is worth a look. Fit not as good as the Squamish but better than the Rab/Montane etc. http://www.norrona.com/Products/0752-09/bitihorn-aero60-Jacket-(M)
Haglofs probably also make something good.
I'm a similar size to you being 6 ft 1 with long arms. I've got a Buffalo Curbar wind top and I use it for running mostly. Decent fit, could do with a bigger integrated hood for my massive head but otherise great. Performs well in strong wind!
Thanks guys, some good advice there.
Inclined to agree with GridNorth re: Boreas. But... Despite not being 100% wind proof I love mine as a second layer on chilly runs or windy days on the rock.
I have a Boreas and don't like it at all. It's sold as sun protection but it's far too hot and sweaty to wear in the sun; it's not as warm as a proper insulating piece nor is it fully windproof.
But I do still reckon it would go well as a warm day summit lunch warm layer over my default base tee and light vest, in preference to an insulating layer.
Bear in mind Boreas is not windproof and doesn't appear to be that water resistant either, but a bit of nikwax helps that bit
Buffalo though if you are prepared to wait a while could make you a longer sleeve option, it will cost extra but you could try for size then say, i want this with a plus 2" sleeve and then in a while you will get it.
Elsewhere on the site
A product review by James Turnbull. James Turnbull at Outside recently took the new Osprey Mutant 38 on a rigorous test in the... Read more
WINTERFEST 2014 at Outside in Hathersage 6th and 7th December 2014 Outside's ever popular Winterfest event is back... Read more
As a long-standing name in the UK rockshoe market, Scarpa have a loyal following and many much-loved models. As a fan... Read more
Nick Livesey discovered the mountains of Snowdonia over a decade ago and finally moved there a year and a half ago, quitting a... Read more
The British climbing scene is very exciting at the moment. It is quite clear that as a sport it is developing at a rapid rate and... Read more