/ What makes a 3 star route?
Personally, I seem to enjoy routes that have a variety of different moves and techniques, so traverses, chimneys, slabs and overhangs, all in one route really do it for me.
Im interested in hearing what everyone else thinks? It seems quite subjective really.
I've also noticed that often really hard routes seem to get lots of stars - not that i will ever climb high e-grades, but it seems a bit like guide writers give stars for bravery sometimes!
It's topropeability is an important factor
The arbitrary opinion of a guidebook writer.
Probably done on a sunny evening after a day of work, then went to the pub after, and had fish and chips on the way home.
when asked "how was the climb?" the writer smiles and thinks back to a perfect day.
The moves, the line and the position. Not necesarily in that order.
Right-hand route is definitely worth stars so where are these comments saying its not worth one? A lot of the difference in stars is related to grade as some better climbers over-state the quality in things they find hard. 3 stars is about line (including some grade related stuff like position exposure etc), the quality of the moves, the history of the route and a few lesser issues like rock quality and good variety and reasonably sustained difficulty. I'd argue that quality of moves on its own should never equate to three stars whch is where the biggest problem comes with 3 star extremes that should be 1 at most. You need two of the big three at least.
I'd add escapability to that list. A route's not quite as good when you can walk off if it gets too hard (unless you're having an epic of course, in which case escapability is a bonus).
> Right-hand route is definitely worth stars so where are these comments saying its not worth one?
I assume from your comment that I (and everyone else on the planet) should know about this route. I'm afraid to say I don't! With a generic name like that though I imagine there are several in the country. Given the grit-centric bias on this site, do I assume this is the case here?
If you search based on what the OP said you every quickly get this (Roaches Skyline was a big clue):
The grit centricity of this site is no more than grit being the most climbed rock in the UK. In that some grit routes get thousands of ascents and posts and thousands of grit routes get no posts (and only a handful of ascents)
My apologies, I had the mist come down and that didn't register, I only seemed to read the subject heading. Sorry agian.
Elsewhere on the site
Rock shoes stink – let’s face it. Boot Bananas are the perfect way to fight the funk and keep them fresh. They help... Read more
Tonight's Friday Night Video features the Norwegian town of Rjukan, once believed to be the home of the world's tallest... Read more
Perhaps the perfect Xmas gift for the climber in your life... Wild Country's Crack School has two of the worlds best crack... Read more
F ounded in 1993, Mountain Hardwear are a pretty young mountaineering clothing and equipment manufacturer but are also one of... Read more
The release of Peter Jackson's new film The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies on 12th December may not appear to link to... Read more