/ Keeping goldfish in a bowl
This came up because I am just watching a TV programme (What Remains) that has a solitary goldfish in a very empty small bowl swimming around aimlessly in a little goldfish bowl on the desk.
Why do we do this? As a species we cannot think that it is humane, or even very interesting. I can see the point in a well stocked aquarium, but a fish in a bowl?
I don't know what 'What Remains' is. Is it a drama? In which case, perhaps the goldfish is actually an actor and is being paid a good wage to swim around looking solitary and aimless, and afterwards will return to an interesting aquarium filled with toys, plastic plants and other goldfish. Is it the same goldfish in every shot? Maybe there are several goldfish job-sharing?
> Maybe there are several goldfish job-sharing?
Given what they say about their memories, would they mind being on a zero-hours contract? Or are their memories better than popular prejudice would have it?
three months apparently
> I don't know what 'What Remains' is. Is it a drama?
At least the goldfish won't have to remember that last scene for longer than 3 months. I think the answer to the title of the prog is "bugger all".
I think your empathy and identification with the fish in this case is perhaps misplaced.
Its not humane and can be stressful for the fish as it has nowhere to hide from potential threats, which in a bowl can come from all angles. Also the shape of a bowl doesn't allow much gaseous transfer at the surface reducing oxygen levels in the water, exacerbated by hot studio lighting (unless a bubbler is used). As well as that, goldfish get large and like lots of space to swim, the 'grow to fit the tank size', is a myth and they are actually stunted with health effects.
But under tv production rules, the fish will be provided by a specialist animal wrangler who will likely remain during the filming to ensure the animal's welfare. The fish probably has its own trailer and will explode into a rage any time a runner brings it a can of diet coke, opened, but with the opening tab not bent back out of the way :)
Still, it's not great to perpetuate the idea of keeping goldfish in small bowls and with no decor.
Moist fish are much more intellegent than we give them credit for.
Many fish, including Goldfish have the capacity to learn and this needs the ability to remember.
Carp (the same family as goldfish) can easily remember what they were caught on previously and will refuse any subsequent baits/hooks/or methods for more than a few months!!. - ask a carp angler.
Many fish are quick to learn. I've taught wild carp to come to the hand to feed and it has recently been discovered that some fish can recognise types of music and learn to respond to some types whilst ignoring others.
A freshwater fish in the middle of the ocean probably has more pressing things to worry about than scenery.
That aside, I'm reasonably certain that deep water fish don't get kept as pets.
Being a goldfish in the middle of the ocean would be fatal. They die of dehydration by osmosis in saltw*ter.
At least in the bowl they don't have to worry about being eaten either! :0)
As opposed to dry fish?
> As opposed to dry fish?
well a dry fish would obviously be very stupid for not staying in the water
Well done!! ;-)
ok I give up ,trying to think of a connection between fish and climbing as this is in rocktalk section ?.
surely this thread should be moved to the "climbers and their fish" forum?
it was in the off belay forum.apologies my mistake. harry and max still with you?
Elsewhere on the site
WINTERFEST 2014 at Outside in Hathersage 6th and 7th December 2014 Outside's ever popular Winterfest event is back... Read more
A product review by James Turnbull. James Turnbull at Outside recently took the new Osprey Mutant 38 on a rigorous test in the... Read more
2014 has been a bumper year for climbing publications. Here's a few of the ones that we have either read, or ones that we... Read more
Nick Livesey discovered the mountains of Snowdonia over a decade ago and finally moved there a year and a half ago, quitting a... Read more
Skiing Baffin’s couloirs has been on my to do list ever since I saw Andrew McLean and Brad Barlage’s inspirational... Read more