/ Strava v Endomondo
I've seen Stava mentioned a few times on UKC now, I currently use Endo...
What are the differences? (I'll look for myself, just wanted to hear your thoughts)
Why Strava over any other tracking apps?
Good question and one I will be looking at closely. I am an Endomondo user, but have used strava a few times recently.
On the face of it for me, very similar. But I havent looked properly at the finer points.
Obvious Strava difference is that you can compare yourself to others who have done same segments.
I've found Strava annoying unstable on my phone though. I have various long rides I've done split into 2 or 3 rides because Strava crashed and I have to restart it so it! Besides that great fun.
Thanks for the comments.
I'm still not sold on Strava though. Most of my friends use Endo and I quite like the fact that we can see each others rides/runs/swims etc.
I'm not really that competitive so wonder if there's a need to switch.
I can use Endo for hours without it draining the battery providing I don't keep checking it, my mate loses power within a couple of hours on it.
You can do the same on Strava, plus also see the rides of complete strangers and then develop a completely irrational hatred of them as they managed to go up a hill in 30 seconds less time than it took you. ;)
I quite like ridewithgps.com
> You can do the same on Strava, plus also see the rides of complete strangers and then develop a completely irrational hatred of them as they managed to go up a hill in 30 seconds less time than it took you. ;)
I've been finding with strava that the altitude gain is sometimes way out, which then makes me think the rest could be out as well. anyone else experience this?
eg. the last ride I remembered to turn it on it was over 1000m too much on the altitude gain for the day. I wish I had done what it said but no chance!!!
All things considered, I think I'll stick with Endo.
Although they don't have a fell running/trail running option.
> I've been finding with strava that the altitude gain is sometimes way out, which then makes me think the rest could be out as well. anyone else experience this?
> eg. the last ride I remembered to turn it on it was over 1000m too much on the altitude gain for the day. I wish I had done what it said but no chance!!!
I often ride with a friend and our Garmins (me 200, and him 500) are often way-out of sync, despite the fact we are doing the same ride.
Distance is not normally too bad, but altitude can be a couple of hundred metres out...very strange
I've a Garmin 510 and my wife has the Garmin 800 and we can find up to a 20% difference in altitude gain over a ride. I'm pretty sure it's my 510 as hers matches other units fairly accurately. The "cure" seems to be to switch it on and not move for a few minutes before you start your ride - there must be some form of calibration going on during this time.
Last week five of us with Garmins doing the same route showed a range in height gain from 1019 to 1047 metres, so roughly 3%. There was a 300 metre range in the distances covered as well but that may be due to when each of us started recording the ride (on a sea front so no altitude changes). The following day there was a similar range in recorded altitude but different units showed the min and max values.
Things like tree cover can affect GPS - I was on a long descent and doing a fairly constant speed yet my GPS showed it varying from 20Kph to 60Kph so presumably altitude is going to be similarly skewed.
As for phones, quite a few segments that have been set up from a ride that someone did with a phone have completely mad elevation profiles. Cat 3 and 4 ratings for something that is flat or goes downhill, or sudden height losses like you've ridden off a cliff. Although Garmins might get the total elevation a little out across a whole ride they are more consistent and you rarely see some of the major errors over a short period of time like you do with a phone. Although does happen occasionally. Once or twice it's plotted me riding out to sea.
thanks for that explanation Escher....i shall use it to feed my desire to upgrade to a 800 :)
I was using both Endo and Strava at the same time to log mountain runs this summer. In reality there wasn't any huge difference but they clearly don't measure in quite the same way as one would get ahead of the other quite randomly. One clear difference was the route trace afterwards: Strava showed a good accurate line whereas Endo only showed a rough curve which ironed out all of the small switchbacks, which was annoying. I doubt it would make much difference when road biking.
Overall I think I prefer the Strava interface and social aspects as well but there's very little in it really.
wow, £i88 for an 800 and £108 for the 500...where's the catch??
ps can anyone please explain to me the difference between the 800 and 810?
Main difference is link up with phone and ability to post ride without plugging it into a PC.
aha, VAT, that old chestnut.
Thanks for clarification
Strrava is the VHS to Endomondo's Phillips 2000/Betamax. it's not necessarily the best quality, but it has got the biggest community and as such is setting the standard. A bit like the UKC logbook, once you start logging your rides with a given system, it's a pain exporting the data and uploading to any alternatives so the more user's invest their time, the les likely they are to leave.
I use to use Stava on my phone, but have since bought a basic Garmin Edge and must say, it works beautifully.
Elsewhere on the site
The British climbing scene is very exciting at the moment. It is quite clear that as a sport it is developing at a rapid rate and... Read more
WINTERFEST 2014 at Outside in Hathersage 6th and 7th December 2014 Outside's ever popular Winterfest event is back... Read more
2014 has been a bumper year for climbing publications. Here's a few of the ones that we have either read, or ones that we... Read more
Nick Livesey discovered the mountains of Snowdonia over a decade ago and finally moved there a year and a half ago, quitting a... Read more
A product review by James Turnbull. James Turnbull at Outside recently took the new Osprey Mutant 38 on a rigorous test in the... Read more