In reply to Andy Moles:
" The consensus to the article from what I would describe as ‘Climbing’s Creative Element’ was overwhelmingly positive. By contrast, the majority of UKC sheep hated it. "
I'm instantly turned off a piece of writing when the author uses this as a means of getting people onside with their argument. "If you agree with me you are cool, if you don't then you are a sheep."
It's lazy and removes the possibility for discussion, as anyone who disagrees with them is a sheep, not worthy of conversing with, and proof of their original statement, rather than a dissenting voice showing the weaknesses of it.
Surely a "creative" writer would have the ability to make his/her point powerfully enough that they were able to leave the ultimate decision up to the reader, safe in the knowledge that they had written their piece well enough, and their point was true enough, that the only logical conclusion is to agree with it. The most staunchly held views and ideals are often those to which you arrive yourself.
My job would be so much easier if all I needed to do to convince a Judge was to put my opening arguments to them and finish with "and if you don't agree with me, you are obviously sheep without any unique thought......and you're a massive dick" (okay so maybe I added that bit at the end about being a dick, but the point still stands)
I had no massive feelings one way or the other towards John Redhead's piece, other than to say that the style wasn't my cup of tea, but why should it be, he didn't write it to please me, he wrote it (seemingly) to prompt debate, and to raise an issue which he thought was important, which makes it all the more ludicrous that a supporter of his uses the phrase above which actively precludes all debate about the subject.
I'll say one thing for Redhead's article, it's certainly prompted a massive debate, as do most things that he does (for better or worse), and surely a healthy and informed debate makes us all the more equipped to form our own opinions....even if the opinions we reach do make us 'the majority of UKC sheep'
Steve
p.s, if you don't agree with what I wrote above it's obviously because you lack the necessary intelligence to fully understand the point I was making, and you are just following the crowd and have no unique thought.
oh, and you're a massive dick.