In reply to TobyA:
> Thanks Damo, the NZ one is the mountain in the Darrens with huge effort just to get to base of it isn't it?
Well, yes and no. It's tough hike up a cold river, but not a long or hard way by NZ backcountry standards, as far as I can tell. One of the things about the climb is the way Guy found it 'easier' than the mythology would have had it. Partly this is because Guy is a very good alpinist, with lots of relevant experience, on his third 'look' at the route, but it's partly also about how we collectively accept judgement about things we really don't know about first-hand, and how standards have progressed.
This is actually similar to the Papert climb in that Linkhu was thought to have been climbed by a French team in the 60s. Quite a few of the peaks in the Rolwaling area have murky histories (Kang Nachugo was also thought to have been climbed before Gottlieb-Puryear did it, but it had not been, and Trakargo possibly *was* climbed before they did it) and the French account had never rung true to me when I'd researched it years ago. Their account just didn't really match what we can now see of the terrain, but I'd just let it slide. Papert's climb made it clear.