In reply to djwilse:
What did you use to secure the new board in place with? If you stuck it in place with dry lining adhesive, that will be fine for filling the gap. You'd probably get away with filling it with plaster, as long as you properly fill it and then cover the joint with fibre tape. Another thing I've seen done is to pack joints with fibre tape and plaster together - whatever you do, make sure that you tape the joint fully after you've filled it, and there's a good overlap - depending on the gap you might need to use two or more strips. If you do fill the joint with plaster then I'd let it go off a little before skimming it, but not completely. If for some reason you do let it go off, then wet it thoroughly before skimming.