In reply to Martin1978:
I have the old version with an unlined palm. I wear a thin merino liner if it's cold. The pile insulation is fixed so you can't pull it out unlike some punishers I tried. The new one has insulation on the palm I think. this sounds perfect. Fairly warm when wet too. (Apart from that palm against an axe(hence liner glove)
Mine are 6-ish years old, done 4-5 weeks of ice and several general trips. Done a bit of stitching and nikwax on the palms. Just starting to blow on the seams this year but got some life left. Seam grip next round of repair. Nice and dexterous and warm enough for a few degrees below. I wear mitts to belay.
I'll get another pair when these die...