In reply to Tom Ripley Mountain Guide:
> Do you count the first 5b pitch or the second 5c pitch as the crux on Redex? I lead the second pitch.
The awkward, grim, vegetated 5c groove at the top. I was well into the pumpy 5b bottom pitch, it was class! Was going to do it in a one-er, but took a 'bottled it' belay just below the crux.
> I'm just unfit so was bound to get spanked on Left Wall. I should try it the weekend after a sport climbing trip.
This is the thing. I had a look at the Pembroke graded list and couldn't really see anything that was decidedly harder than LW (except Silver Shadow?), but that's because I've generally been to Pembroke after wall training and a summer of trad and found the steep jug-pulling fun to be a laugh. If you're technically able and strong-fingered but unfit, Pembroke could feel nails.
Back to the list, from the SW:
Bow Wall, West Face Direct, Xanadu(?), Green Cormorant Face(?). I found Suicide Wall and Thin Wall Special harder than LW too!