In reply to Jim C:
> On the devo side, I'd devolve some more - but not all - tax raising. I quite like Scottish Lab's recent proposals, that's the sort of level.
> Really!
> You are ahead of me Dan, I listened to Lamont try explain it, and it was embarrassing, and incomprehensible . If you read some of the comments below this article, I am not alone.
> john macmillan, helensburgh • 5 hours ago
> I,like many others,saw Ms.Lamont on tv explaining her proposals.I,like many others,could not understand one word of what she said.Could someone help me out here?
> JAMES MORRISEY john macmillan, helensburgh • 5 hours ago
> I don't think Ms.Lamont understood it, Gordon Brewer filleted both her and her Devo Nano during the interview
> Dr Douglas McKenzie john macmillan, helensburgh • 3 hours ago
> If you listen carefully to the broadcast you will hear someone laughing their head off in the background.
> Jon Legorburu, Ayr Dr Douglas McKenzie • an hour ago
> I was even embarrassed for her.
> JAMES MORRISEY • 5 hours ago
> This Devo Nano is designed to put Scotland at a disadvantage to the UK if it ever used these powers.
> Total shambles from the British nationalist of UK Labour's regional branch office in Scotland.
> Malcolm McCandless • 5 hours ago
> A really embarrassing and damaging episode for Scottish Labour and Johann Lamont in particular.
> Labour have now ruled themselves out of the referendum debate as it will be nigh impossible to sell these badly flawed devo-plans to Scots in the run up to Sept 18th.
> Only the Tories can save the union now. Oh how the SNP will be relishing that prospect.
> Steve McKay • 4 hours ago
> If I was still a Labour supporter I would be furious at the incompetent and insulting devolution proposals put forward by my party - after two years of thinking and planning!
> Actually I am furious - but at least I'm not embarrassed. Labour in Scotland have been reduced to a bumbling incoherent laughing stock. The fact that even their own leadership south of the border are in on the joke must surely be the last straw.
> Andrew McBride • 4 hours ago
> Should good fun watching Johann Lamont explain why she's right and Reform Scotland are wrong when she's next on Newsnight.
> stewart short, glasgow • 3 hours ago
> One of my favourites, back of a fag packet. economic catastrophy for the forgotten socialist party,poor Joane hung out to dry.
>
> Alastair Gordon, West Lothian • 27 minutes ago
> It's difficult to believe wee JoLa would get this one wrong.
> (Stop laughing at the back!)
I've never seen a post so long without a single reason put across. Are we posting comments now? Incredible, we're usually laughing at dailymail comments not using vacuous 30 character tripe to susbstantiate an argument.