In reply to kingjam:
Hi,
In my experience, the simple answer is yes. Climbing hand balms are better at keeping your hands in good condition and do so for longer. However, how much this is true depends on which balm you are using and which moisturiser you are comparing it against. I did a review of hand balms for climbers for my blog and you might find it useful (see
http://thesevereclimber.com/2014/02/23/a-better-balm-review-of-hand-balms-f... ). Generally, I'd recommend Climb On and Sypeland.
Hope that helps.