In reply to EwanKennedy:
Just been through the same dilemma. As said above, differnt shoes for different things, and different shoes for different feet.
Some of the recent 'epic TV - climbing daily' episodes have done a series of shoes comparisons with banana fingers, sorted by what you want out of a shoe. Look for them on youtube or the epic TV app.
After watching them, I whittled down the choices, then I went to the shop and tried them all on, and got proper advice.
After that I whittled it down to two, and I chose the ones I did, because I felt the other were more advanced than I needed.