In reply to Jim 1003:
We did Totalitarian (E1) on Raven Crag Thirlmere in 2013 and it was great - neither dirty nor loose, 3 good pitches. We did have to climb a pitch of vegetation to get to the start of the route but it was fine.
To the OP - I appreciate this isn't a recent ascent! I wish more people would log their routes as it can be a good way of guessing conditions even if not commented on.
If it helps anyone - I've been slightly off the beaten track on popular crags recently:
Black Crag Eliminate E1 (Black Crag Borrowdale) had some dirty but climbable bits and a dirty and unclimbable bit for me but I combined it with the adjacent route to make a worthwhile outing - see my logbook.
Chimney Variant E1 on White Ghyll - the crux groove looks dirty but the holds are clean. And i went round the wet bit in the chimney.
Post edited at 07:30