In reply to Alan James - Rockfax:
The problems 9 and 10 marked on the east of the boulder in '98 match the grades and descritions there and roughly match the older AW problems. We grade checked 10 and some unlisted neighbours as VB 4a, so I still can't see where your V1 5b is round there (your topo maps in '98 were amazingly accurate.. a true labour of love). The BMC named problems, on the SW side, quite reasonably seemed newly listed to me, partly as the rock step they are next to was clearly marked on the '98 topo. You use the BMC names for those problems in '14 and they match your descriptions and your grades. The BMC topo also shows where they go (no arrows). Hence, I still don't know from what you are saying what exactly is wrong in which way in your guides (it makes more sense to me if you climbed the two BMC listed problems in '98 such that the positions on the '98 topo were wrong) but it is clear now that those two problems hadn't been left out in '14 so I apologise for that incorrect deduction. Our scripts, which we make public, are currently in error because of that deduction and correcting that is not pointless for me.
As for the original point there are 3 other problems missing on the B south valley boulders which are not posible to be mistaken identities. Otherwise the odd problems lost here and there add up. There is probably more than a handful behind the Roaches Attic, and some on the Froggatt Pinnacle boulders of just those I can remember off the top of my head... I haven't got a list and don't have time now and the odd one or two might also be mistaken identiites but we must be talking well into the tens.
Oh and on the plus side Heighly Castle was dropped and the back left of the far Skyline group and Eagle Tor ... and Eastwood ... left out down to your access concerns (so I wasn't counting them).
Post edited at 09:23