In reply to twid:
Hi Twid,
Don't take it too seriously. I've got nothing but respect for the shed-loads of amazing looking routes you have done worldwide, which - as ever with the often gritcentric naval-gazing british magazines - get pretty much ignored. My point wasn't that I'm shit-hot, rather the reverse I'm afraid. I'm a very average punter who leads E1 on a good day, but I seconded Doseth Crack cleanly so E4 for a well protected route seemed rather generous. I don't know if you did Swedish Corner also at Kalle, but I had done that a few days previously with one fall whilst trying to lead it. Others better than me suggested E2 for that, so I would have thought something similar for Doseth Crack.
As to sad people being hung up on grades... you are probably right. I'm sad because I'm not going to Norway this year; I've got the flu; its peeing down with rain outside anyway; and since my lovely-but-so-far-uninterested-in-climbing son came a long 9 weeks ago I've managed three roped routes and a few sessions of bouldering and that's it. So the warm granite and perfect handjams of Lofoten are just memories...
Sorry for any offence given.
Toby.
p.s. Has anyone else done "The Ape" at Kalle? I think the Webster guide gives it Norwegian 6 or 5.10. I would love to say it's an E1, but I suspect that if it was in Yorkshire it would get VS.