Derbyshire > Stanage Popular >
 
Fragile Mantel VS 5a

Adjacent Climbs
<< Mantelpiece Buttress Direct
 
Mantelpiece Right >>
8m. Climb past the right-hand edge of the narrow overhang by a long reach for the ledge. Finish easily. © ROCKFAX
FA. Chris Craggs 1993
Submit a new photo of this climb.

PUBLIC LOGBOOKS
This climb is in 164 logbooks, and on no wishlists.

Lack of reach and power in right arm.
Maciekman - Sent dnf - 11/Sep/14

Senna - Solo O/S - 05/Sep/14

A wet and windy day!
benthomas.online - 2nd O/S - 17/Aug/14 with Robin Edwards

Nick1812P - Solo O/S - 09/Aug/14

robblowen - Solo rpt - 04/Aug/14

mattpw - Lead O/S - 26/Jul/14 with Nick Butler

Hardcore Pat - Solo rpt - 15/Jul/14

Hidden - Solo O/S - 22/Jun/14

Matthew Ferrier - Solo O/S - 13/Jun/14 with Alex McCann

teaching friend to lead*
simontyrrell - Lead - 25/May/14

set up bottom ropes taking a group of 6 climbing
simontyrrell - 25/May/14

Hidden - Solo O/S - 19/May/14

Hidden - Solo - 09/May/14

ashtond6 - Solo O/S - 09/May/14

marcduhig - Solo O/S - 03/May/14

robblowen - Solo O/S - 09/Apr/14

David Kay - Solo O/S - 05/Apr/14

Hidden - 2nd rpt - 30/Mar/14

robgixer - Solo - 14/Mar/14

4c is fair enough, perhaps even easier for the tall.
jshields - Solo - 16/Nov/13

Anna Hammond - Lead O/S - 10/Nov/13 with Jake Carey

Hardcore Pat - Solo rpt - 26/Sep/13

Jimbo C - Solo O/S - 21/Sep/13

TimPerkin - TR - 20/Sep/13 with Mike Porter, Richard Harris

atom - Solo - 05/Sep/13

Overgraded here. The HS 4c it's given in the current definitive guide is nearer the mark.
cem - Solo O/S - 14/Aug/13

slacky - Lead O/S - 13/Jun/13 with Ben

Hidden - Solo rpt - 10/Jun/13

Hidden - 2nd - 06/Jun/13

Lumbering Oaf - Solo O/S - 31/May/13

Laramadness - Solo O/S - 20/Apr/13

Radical-G - Solo O/S - 07/Apr/13

leeoftroy - Lead O/S - Apr/13

pie_eater_pete - Solo O/S - 03/Mar/13 with bwestwood

bwestwood - Solo - 03/Mar/13 with pete sargeant

Mark Collins - Lead O/S - 13/Oct/12 with Neil Henson

Hidden - Solo - 06/Sep/12

harold walmsley - Solo rpt - 30/Aug/12

Martin Rowe - Solo O/S - 16/Aug/12

JamieSparkes - Solo rpt - 12/Aug/12 with Fergus Cuthill, Tom Eadington

The Big Sender - Solo O/S - 12/Aug/12

dannyboy83 - Solo O/S - 14/Jul/12

treg - Solo O/S - 29/Jun/12

Mr Tickle - Solo O/S - 14/Jun/12

adam carless - Solo rpt - 28/May/12

tompilgrem - Lead O/S - 10/Mar/12 with Dad

bobpilgrem - 2nd O/S - 10/Mar/12 with Tom

ChrisBrooke - Lead O/S - 25/Feb/12 with John Inkpen

deacondeacon - Solo - 2012

Hidden - 2012

Hidden - Solo O/S - 14/Nov/11

not worth it
dr_botnik - 2nd dog - 05/Nov/11 with Chris Daly-Roy

peterbull - Solo - 15/Sep/11

al123 - Solo - 24/Aug/11

SteveM - Solo - 14/Jul/11

adi bryant - Solo - 03/Jul/11

Hidden - Solo O/S - 02/Jul/11

t_stork - Lead - 26/Jun/11 with Anna Wells

Anna_wells - 2nd - 26/Jun/11 with Tom _ Stork

Ben Harper - Solo O/S - 12/Jun/11 with Ed Westwood

garburn - Solo O/S - 12/Jun/11 with Laura, Ben Harper, Gideon Mordecai, Ed Westwood

jw231 - Solo O/S - 04/Jun/11 with Alex Skew

Hidden - Solo O/S - 29/May/11

john lynch - Solo O/S - 17/May/11 with kela

TRFrost - Solo O/S - 16/May/11

ankyo - Solo - 19/Apr/11

PeteH - Solo O/S - 18/Apr/11

oddessy_uk - Solo O/S - 09/Apr/11

Hidden - Lead O/S - 09/Apr/11

Jonathan Hall - Solo - 22/Mar/11

disturbed_one51 - Solo - 22/Mar/11

lithos - Solo - 22/Mar/11

harold walmsley - Solo rpt - 14/Mar/11

lozowen - Solo - 08/Feb/11

Hidden - Lead O/S - 2011

mwatson - 2011

Hidden - 2011

jade - 2nd - 2011 with andy

Hidden - Dec/10

jade - 2nd - Oct/10 with andy

JamieSparkes - Solo O/S - 21/Sep/10

tomthecoolperson - Sent O/S - 10/Sep/10 with Andrew

Sam Simpson - Solo O/S - 26/Jul/10

ptigga - 2nd - 23/Jun/10

Hidden - Lead O/S - 19/May/10

Mr Powly - Solo - 28/Apr/10

Matt Bennett - Solo O/S - 07/Mar/10 with Sam Corbett, Lewis Grey

Hidden - 2010

DaveB61 - TR - 30/Oct/09 with Pete Howlett

Peter Howlett - TR O/S - 30/Oct/09

The Bad Cough - Solo O/S - 23/Aug/09

Hidden - Solo O/S - 02/Aug/09

pabbage - Solo O/S - Aug/09

Somerset swede basher - Solo O/S - 09/Jul/09

Tom Last - Solo O/S - 04/Jul/09

Whealiebob - 2nd O/S - 01/Jul/09 with Stee

vanderz - Solo O/S - 26/Jun/09

hang_about - 2nd - 21/Jun/09

Jon Dittman - Solo - 09/Jun/09

Andy Fielding - Solo - 02/May/09

stevemcg - Lead - 19/Apr/09 with Matt

Hidden - Solo O/S - 06/Apr/09

howlingbaboon - Solo O/S - 01/Apr/09

Hidden - Sent O/S - 30/Mar/09

tlr - Solo - 20/Mar/09

Hidden - Solo rpt - 06/Mar/09

simonp - Solo O/S - Mar/09

johniebriggs - Lead - Mar/09

tomguyowenhall - 2nd - Mar/09

Shad - Lead - Mar/09

Hidden - Sent - 2009

JackMountains - Solo O/S - 25/Sep/08

Hidden - Solo O/S - 17/Sep/08

Brown - Solo O/S - 08/Sep/08

craig d - Solo - 30/Aug/08

petemeads - Solo - 29/Aug/08

Mattyk - Solo O/S - 21/Jul/08

adam carless - Solo O/S - 29/Jun/08

Hidden - Solo - 16/Jun/08

Andy Clarke - Solo O/S - 08/Jun/08

mel holmes - Solo - 04/Jun/08

Hidden - AltLd - 11/Apr/08

Hidden - Solo - 09/Apr/08

TrollJester - AltLd O/S - 2008 with VARIOUS Throughout 80's+90's

Hidden - 2008

Hidden - Solo O/S - 11/Dec/07

DerwentDiluted - Solo - 09/Oct/07

LankyPaddy - Solo O/S - 06/Oct/07

Hidden - Solo - 05/Oct/07

Hidden - Solo O/S - 20/Sep/07

jdgaventa - Solo - 25/Aug/07

popebenedictus - TR O/S - 23/Aug/07 with Ruth Harding

Powder Puff Girl - TR O/S - 23/Aug/07 with Ben H

Powder Puff Girl - TR rpt - 23/Aug/07 with Edd R

edd rab - TR O/S - 23/Aug/07 with Ben Harding

Jim Vach - Solo O/S - 11/May/07

Mike Lee - Lead - 12/Apr/07 with Donna

Hidden - Solo - 04/Mar/07

Graeme Hammond - Solo O/S - 02/Mar/07

Hidden - Solo O/S - 03/Feb/07

Hidden - 2007

Hidden - Solo O/S - 17/Sep/06

Stig - Solo O/S - 06/Jun/06

Hidden - Lead - 04/Apr/06

mikecopp - Solo - 04/Apr/06

Tobias at Home - 2006

richw2k2 - 2nd - 23/Oct/05 with Craig ?

Nicos - Solo O/S - 26/Sep/05 with solo

Pythonist - Solo O/S - 30/Aug/05

easy enough
Alex Mason - Lead - 31/May/05 with jools holland

loonyclimber - Solo - May/05

Dave Mason - 2nd O/S - Aug/04

Dave Mason - 2nd O/S - Aug/04

Hidden - Solo O/S - Jul/04

Hidden - Solo O/S - 24/May/04

ChrisJD - Lead - 22/May/04 with Clare

Hidden - 2nd - 12/Apr/04

Neil Curtis - Lead O/S - 05/Oct/03 with Ursula Augsdorfer

Hidden - Solo - 23/Feb/03

Iain Thow - Solo - 13/Feb/03

Hidden - Solo O/S - 27/May/02

Jon Greengrass - 2002

Hidden - 2000

Hidden - Solo O/S - 2000

Voting
Total votes cast 48
hard HVS0 of 18
HVS0 of 18
easy HVS0 of 18
hard VS0 of 18
VS4 of 18
easy VS10 of 18
hard HS3 of 18
HS1 of 18
easy HS0 of 18
hard 5b0 of 18
5b0 of 18
easy 5b0 of 18
hard 5a0 of 18
5a9 of 18
easy 5a5 of 18
hard 4c2 of 18
4c2 of 18
easy 4c0 of 18
3 Stars1 of 12
2 Stars1 of 12
1 Star6 of 12
0 Stars4 of 12
Bag of .....0 of 12
Please Login as Existing User to rate this climb.
Style of ascent

Soloed104 of 164 (63.4%)
Lead20 of 164 (12.2%)
Followed16 of 164 (9.8%)
Toproped7 of 164 (4.3%)
Bouldered4 of 164 (2.4%)
Alt Leads2 of 164 (1.2%)
Unknown11 of 164 (6.7%)

'Climbed'66 of 164 (40.2%)
clean O/S85 of 164 (51.8%)
clean rpt11 of 164 (6.7%)
dogged1 of 164 (0.6%)
dnf1 of 164 (0.6%)