Derbyshire > Froggatt Edge >
 
Brown's Eliminate Direct** E3 5c

Adjacent Climbs
<< Straight and Narrow
 
Brown's Eliminate >>
[John Lynch, Brown's eliminate direct, E3 5c, Froggatt., 2 kb]Bolder and harder than the original, with the same runners. The lower arete has a tough sequence to the ledge, the upper section eases after more tricky and precarious moves. © ROCKFAX

Photo: John Lynch, Brown's eliminate direct, E3 5c, Froggatt. © john lynch
View all 4 photos or Submit a new photo of this climb.

PUBLIC LOGBOOKS
This climb is in 103 logbooks, and on 4 wishlists.

Hidden - TR O/S - 01/Jul/14

Hidden - TR O/S - 22/Jun/14

First E3 onsight on Outcrop Grit. Upper moves felt a little scary.
MischaHY - Lead O/S - 22/Jun/14 with Leo Woodhead

Tried before but ended up doing straight and narrow. Almost dropped the move to the break too. Climbing pretty poorly recently. Oh well.
deacondeacon - Lead - 09/May/14

radioshed - 2nd O/S - 19/Apr/14 with dave s

jshields - 2nd - 16/Mar/14 with Mike Lea, Paul Tretheway

ashtond6 - 2nd O/S - 15/Mar/14

Fell once trying to make the move just above the ledge, but clean otherwise
Teappleby - TR dog - 04/Dec/13 with Jake Shaw

Hidden - Lead O/S - 06/Oct/13

Lev - Lead O/S - 21/Sep/13 with Emma Ross

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 21/Sep/13

After bailing off last time onto the original, it was good to stick that high foot match! Tricky.
Dr Toph - Solo O/S - 31/Aug/13

sgl0jd - Solo - 15/Apr/13

Nick Sillem - Lead O/S - 2013

Matt Harle - Lead O/S - 11/Nov/12

keithpeck - 2nd O/S - 14/Oct/12 with Anthony Allsopp

Anthony Allsopp - Lead O/S - 14/Oct/12

Danny Crump - TR - 16/Sep/12 with Sarah Pentelow

felt hard
Nick1812P - 2nd O/S - 01/Sep/12

Immediately after original. Class.
ianjfsutcliffe - Lead O/S - 22/Jul/12 with Kenny

Hidden - 2012

Hidden - TR dog - 19/Nov/11

maffujones - Lead - 22/Oct/11 with Zuzana Deans

mwatson - 19/Oct/11

Peter Holder - Lead O/S - 14/Sep/11

ColinD - TR O/S - 04/May/11

Defo tricky moves off the ledge. Pretty safe though.
PeteH - Lead O/S - 07/Mar/11 with Mark Watson, Chris Fox

Hidden - Lead O/S - 06/Mar/11

andy_e - TR O/S - 06/Mar/11

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 29/Jan/11

very good
masonwoods101 - Lead O/S - 2011

mwatson - 2011

got on some blokes top rope just to give the moves a try, cheap shoes screwed me up by making my smears insecure, so I fell off the lower crux, but was fine on the upper crux.
Aaron Hauptmann - TR dog - 30/Oct/10 with Danny Salvadori

olly12344 - TR dog - 30/Oct/10

Nice climbing all the way up. I found the crux to be the second move past the ledge, not the one getting onto the ledge.
Alkis - TR RP - 30/Oct/10 with Oliver Hill

Hidden - TR β - 05/Aug/10

chris sm - 2nd O/S - 24/Jul/10 with Jon Pearson

Hidden - Lead - 24/Jul/10

nia - TR - 15/May/10 with Fred Mainwaring

BeccaSnowden - 2nd RP - 14/Apr/10

Oliver Houston - 2nd - 14/Apr/10

Awesome! Finishing up the original skips the hard bit...
thomasadixon - Lead O/S - 14/Apr/10 with Ollie Houston, Becca

Fantastic! so good ive gotta go back and lead it sometime
freddieneame10 - 2nd - Apr/10

Finishing up the arete instead of the original felt a bit artificial.
kingholmesy - Lead O/S - 2010 with Andy S

bigie bob - Lead O/S - 31/Oct/09

Ceridwen - 2nd O/S - 31/Oct/09 with Bob

On Andy's cams after belaying him for an hour (or two). Great lead as he didn't look happy at any point. First E3, albeit with beta.
Dave Foster - Lead β - 18/Oct/09 with Andy

felixthelion - Lead O/S - 27/Sep/09 with Rob

mgeek - Lead O/S - 23/Sep/09 with adam hughes

akhughes - Lead O/S - 23/Sep/09 with Mgeek, Andy Innes, Emma Hughes

Tithe Technique - TR - 16/Sep/09 with Angela Paul, Charley

valentinesbabe - TR dnf - 16/Sep/09 with Kevin Tithe

Comedy upside down fall off the tricky move on the upper arete, fairly safe as my head ended up at least 2 metres off the ground! Got it second go.
Misha - Lead dog - 21/Mar/09

Hidden - 2nd rpt - 18/Mar/09

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 06/Mar/09

john lynch - Lead O/S - 06/Mar/09 with Lewis Andrew, rich armour

Lewis Andrew - Lead O/S - 06/Mar/09 with John Lynch, Rich Armour

pretty tough for me, no mistakes apart from a shockin mantel ontae the shelf, nice climbin above tho..
fatbuoybazza - TR O/S - 31/Jan/09 with olivia

Hidden - TR dog - Jan/09

Brown - Lead O/S - 07/Dec/08 with Henry

lukea - 2nd O/S - 28/Sep/08 with felix

chadrads - TR RP - 24/Sep/08 with adrian berry

barni - Lead - 27/Aug/08 with Jack

Hidden - Lead O/S - 28/Jun/08

Hidden - 2nd O/S - 20/May/08

Nom - TR O/S - 16/Apr/08 with Joe Bream

Hidden - TR O/S - 16/Apr/08

Finished up original and used a mat. Great Climbing. First E3 (if finishing up original and using a mat is still worth that grade)!!
tommytuffa - Lead - 07/Feb/08 with luketheape

Hidden - Solo O/S - 07/Oct/07

followed barros up it. swapped places on the ledge and finished up original.
Ram MkiV - Solo β - 07/Oct/07 with Alex B, Alex M, Toby

Chad123 - AltLd O/S - 09/Sep/07 with Emily and Numpty

Finished up Brown's Eliminate.
Jon Read - Lead rpt - 24/Jul/07 with Debs

Hidden - Lead - May/07

Joe Dove - 2nd - 2007 with kev

steve taylor - 2007

Hidden - 2007

dannyboy83 - Lead O/S - Feb/04

Duncan I - Lead O/S - 2002

RossG - 2000

An interesting alternative start.
Sean Kelly - Lead - May/95 with Keith Bolton

If this is the same as "Straight and Narrow" E2 (5c).
jim_randell - TR O/S - 10/Jul/94

IanD353 - Solo O/S - Mar/93

craig d - 1993

Nick Rundall - 2nd O/S - 1990

Hidden - Solo - 1989

Hidden - 1989

mark-abz - TR - 01/Sep/87 with Andy W

mark mcgowan01 - 1986

mark mcgowan01 - 1986

Tom V - 1986

Nic Robinson - Solo rpt - 19/Feb/83

ewar woowar - Solo - 1982

Hidden - Solo - 05/Jun/81

Mark Kemball - Lead RP - 24/May/81

Hidden - Solo - 07/May/81

Hidden - Solo - 10/Apr/81

Ghastly Rubberfeet - Solo - 1981

Hidden - Solo O/S - Apr/80

Nic Robinson - Solo O/S - 20/Feb/80

Andy Fielding - TR - 1980

Hidden - Solo O/S - 1978

andy gittins - 1978

KRB - Solo O/S - 31/Jul/77

Users with this climb on their wishlist are:
natalietanzer, sean0409, James Oakes, Pythonist

Voting
Total votes cast 71
hard E40 of 24
E40 of 24
easy E41 of 24
hard E33 of 24
E315 of 24
easy E33 of 24
hard E22 of 24
E20 of 24
easy E20 of 24
hard 6a0 of 25
6a0 of 25
easy 6a1 of 25
hard 5c8 of 25
5c14 of 25
easy 5c2 of 25
hard 5b0 of 25
5b0 of 25
easy 5b0 of 25
3 Stars9 of 22
2 Stars11 of 22
1 Star2 of 22
0 Stars0 of 22
Bag of .....0 of 22
Please Login as Existing User to rate this climb.
Style of ascent

Soloed16 of 103 (15.5%)
Lead34 of 103 (33.0%)
Followed18 of 103 (17.5%)
Toproped22 of 103 (21.4%)
Alt Leads1 of 103 (1.0%)
Unknown12 of 103 (11.7%)

'Climbed'35 of 103 (34.0%)
clean O/S51 of 103 (49.5%)
clean β3 of 103 (2.9%)
clean rpt3 of 103 (2.9%)
clean RP4 of 103 (3.9%)
dogged6 of 103 (5.8%)
dnf1 of 103 (1.0%)