Tom Livingstone - Style Matters Article

© Tom Livingstone

Tom Livingstone reflects on what style means to him in the context of climbing, and beyond...

Marko Lukić held the room to attention. In a rare presentation, the Slovenian climber spoke of his long career, which included early repeats of hard sport routes (Just Do It, 8c) and alpine climbs around the world (No Siesta, Jorasses (free ascent)). We - young British alpinists, visiting Slovenia to sample their infamous winter climbing - listened intently.

Uisdean Hawthorn, Chantel Astorga and Anne Gilbert Chase looking back towards the south face of Denali, Alaska.
© Tom Livingstone

A shaft of light from the projector cut the dark room. Marko, glasses glinting, paused in his story. Dust particles floated slowly through the beam, spinning and falling, but we took no notice. All we saw was a single photo glimmering on the screen: a climber in the mountains, a ribbon of steep ice, and a large backpack. Just one of Marko's many climbs; it looked hard and committing.

Marko spoke. 'One of the most important things to remember, is that style matters.'

I agreed with Marko: the way we climb is as important as what we climb. Over the last few years, I've come to realise there's more to climbing than simply reaching a summit or topping out a route. Climbing is more than just a physical act or mental fight. Style is all we have. Otherwise, why not just take a helicopter to the top?

Marko continued his presentation. 'After Just Do It, I was injured, so I went alpine climbing,' he said with a smile. Marko embodied style throughout his climbing and encouraged us to always aim high.

'Style matters because you're trying to meet the challenge in the best possible way,' he said. 'Onsight and free is the fairest. Style reflects you, and shows you aimed for the ideal - even if you didn't make it.' This struck a chord with me, and I thought about my own pursuit of style…

When it all works out (just). Belaying at the ‘bucket seat belay’ at the end of pitch 2, Skinhead Moonstomp (E6 6b)
© Tom Livingstone

In rock climbing, the cleanest style is obviously onsight; preferably near your limit, on a classic route and with a good battle to the top. The experience is raw, the result uncertain. To accept beta, to top rope, or to reduce the challenge of the route is a lesser style. The result might be a quicker ascent, or an easier experience, but it can almost feel like cheating.

Alpinism is a search for the purest style in the mountains: no fixed ropes, no oxygen, no assistance. I relate to Marko's 'style' statement most when alpine climbing. I'm drawn to alpinism because it's a culmination of all my skills and knowledge. Anything less would not be enough: I want a challenge which pushes back, which forces me to draw on my experience. I cherish the adventure in climbing.

When it all works out (almost). Tony Stone on the American Route on the Aiguille du Fou, Mont Blanc Massif.
© Tom Livingstone

I also like aesthetics, so striking, beautiful mountains draw me in. I find satisfaction in climbing a thousand metres of ice, snow and rock over many days. Just look at Mt. Alberta in the Canadian Rockies, Mt. Jezebel in Alaska, or Aiguille du Fou in the Alps. I felt the fear before climbing these picturesque mountains, but thanks to strong partners, we always aimed for a free ascent - even if we didn't succeed!

Of course, the longer and more sustained the route, the more enjoyable the game becomes. But also, the more important it is to choose wisely: up or down? The higher we climb, the greater the consequences - and the easier it is to opt for a lesser style. Once we passed the crux of Divine Providence on the Grand Pilier d'Angle, it was much more logical to continue upwards than to consider bailing down, for example.

Style is embodied in adventure of the unknown. A guaranteed route in the mountains holds no appeal. For me, alpinism is starting in the dead of night, following the white light of hope from your headlamp. It's filling your lungs with cold air, wondering where each breath will take you. It's the crunch of granite crystals beneath your rock shoes and the uncertainty as the axe strikes.

The greater the unknown in alpine climbing, the greater the chance of failure (the concept of failure, in itself, is incorrect. We can learn from every outcome). But the greater the potential reward. Remember the feelings of satisfaction, relief and pride after a hard-won onsight? I felt electric for days after my first hard trad onsight. I floated on a steady buzz, contented, even though I can only remember a few of the moves from Surgical Lust (a climb on Scimitar Ridge). A few years before, I was tempted to headpoint a route of this E7 grade, but now I'm glad I saved it for the onsight.

Tony Stone - a man who knows a lot about style - waiting to hitch a ride back to town in Patagonia.  © Tom Livingstone
Tony Stone - a man who knows a lot about style - waiting to hitch a ride back to town in Patagonia.
© Tom Livingstone

These are the rewards we should aim for as we pursue the ephemeral 'perfect style.' We should look for the views with nobody else in sight, and chase the blood-red sunset. We should remember the silence as darkness settles, and the comfort of a star-lit sky. But it isn't always easy; the remoteness of the Karakoram certainly made me question my motives, my style and my tolerance of fear.

I like that the best style in alpine climbing is to pare down everything to the essential - equipment, mind, partnership. Cutting the labels out of jackets does nothing for the weight of my pack, but does everything for my mind. And I like that the best style requires the burning of all energy, the combination of psyche... it's the sum of everything.

Aiming for the best style in climbing means I have to try harder than I want. I have to face my demons and explore fear. Being shit-scared above 'junk pro' certainly focuses my attention. Even whilst Scottish winter climbing, I've found myself going far beyond my comfort zone and silently praying my picks would hold. Beinn Eighe's frozen quartzite walls are a cocktail of tempting lines and thin hooks, which lure me in before sending shivers down my spine - and not just from the cold.

Uisdean walking out from an attempt on Mt. Alberta’s north face in 2015.
© Tom Livingstone

Fellow British climber Uisdean Hawthorn and I recently named our new route in Alaska "Fun or Fear" because we regularly experienced both these emotions.

Style translates to life, too. If you opt for the guaranteed tick or pull on gear when the going gets tough, you change the challenge. Do you take the easy way in life?


Marko Prezelj, another man who knows a lot about style.
© Tom Livingstone

But of course, I've bailed, failed, fallen off, burnt out, been scared, focused on the ground and wasted many opportunities. I've lost racks-worth of gear, and abseiled off single wires again and again (why do I always lose size 5s?). Young and less experienced, I didn't take many of the leads on the Gabarrou-Silvy on the Aiguille Sans Nom with Calum and John - even though they offered. I've shouted "take!" and dropped a rope down projects I should've saved for the onsight. And now I bitterly regret it.

But, equally, I've pushed on into the night. My partners and I have weathered the storm, hungry and smiling. I've shared some of my richest life experiences with good friends in the mountains and now, every time I tie in, I remember the question - or the challenge: in what style can I do this?

Kendal Mountain Festival  © KMF
Kendal Mountain Festival 2018

Kendal Mountain Festival (15th-18th November) is an award-winning event that has grown in size and diversity over the last 18 years. It is also the main social event for outdoor enthusiasts in the UK. Thousands of outdoor enthusiasts plus media industry specialists, athletes, top brands & equipment manufacturers, artists, photographers, adventurers, explorers and inspirational speakers gather every year to share adventures and celebrate the very best in outdoor and adventure sports culture.

Tom Livingstone will be speaking at the Mountain Equipment High Mountain Session (Sun 18th November AM) hosted by Stephen Venables alongside Chantal Astorga.


Tom Livingstone is a climber and writer based in North Wales, UK.

He has a penchant for trad, winter and alpine climbing - the bigger and harder, the better.

Tom is an acclaimed outdoor writer, and you can...

Tom's Athlete Page 13 posts 3 videos

Support UKC

As climbers we strive to make UKClimbing the kind of website we would love to visit, with the most up-to-date news, diverse and interesting articles, comprehensive gear reviews, breathtaking photographs and a vast and useful logbook system. As a result, an incredible community has formed around the site - we’ve provided the framework but it’s you who make the website what it is today. If you appreciate the content we offer then you can help us by becoming an official UKC Supporter. This can be a one-off single annual payment or a more substantial payment paid monthly or yearly which includes full access to Rockfax Digital and discounts on Rockfax print publications.

If you appreciate UKClimbing then please help us by becoming a UKC Supporter.

UKC Supporter

  • Support the website we all know and love
  • Access to a year's subscription to Rockfax Digital.
  • Plus 30% off Rockfax guidebooks
  • Plus Show your support UKC porter badge on your profile and forum posts
UKC/UKH/Rockfax logo

20 Sep, 2018

The decision to onsight rather than work a route is all about embracing uncertainty and a rich experience (and likely fall potential!). I found this bit interesting:

"I felt electric for days after my first hard trad onsight. I floated on a steady buzz, contented, even though I can only remember a few of the moves from Surgical Lust (a climb on Scimitar Ridge). A few years before, I was tempted to headpoint a route of this E7 grade, but now I'm glad I saved it for the onsight."

I can understand being pleased not to have worked a particular route, but personally I don't find that headpointing the next grade up in any way reduces the powerful experience of the later onsight of a different route.  

20 Sep, 2018

Struggling to work out why, as of 20:50, there are 4 dislikes for this post! 

(I "liked" it, just for balance)

20 Sep, 2018

Envy or even jealousy ?

Climb in whatever style you like, but do not think it does not matter.

So did I.


20 Sep, 2018

In reply :

Style matters. 

Onsighting close to your limit is incredibly satisfying. 

However risk also matters. 

I've done bold routes and felt sickened afterwards at how close it was; at how much I'd risked; and for what?

I want to play this game for a long time, and not cripple myself. So I'm prepared to occasionally sacrifice style. Not often, and always honestly. I don't feel bad about it. I don't need total commitment every time I go out. 

20 Sep, 2018

Or you could always sacrifice odd E point instead :-)

Lovely little article.

More Comments

Loading Notifications...
Facebook Twitter Copy Email LinkedIn Pinterest