In reply to ripper:
> Are people setting their expectation levels rather too high? Come on, none of the Bond films have actually been THAT good, they're all pretty preposterous.
Respectfully, no.
With the Daniel Craig incarnation, the producers and studio and press have been hyping it all up as a "proper gritty Bond, none of the silly gadgets and innuendos of the Moore era" etc. etc. Harking back to the novels and all that.
Arguably they achieved this with Casino Royale but that film is actually a bit boring for it (only 3 major action set-pieces and 2 minor ones, with the bulk of the film being a card game)
QoS was filmed in a style that was an obvious kneejerk reaction to Paul Greengrass' Bourne "shakycam" and choppy close-ups style, which really took away from what was alway good about action in Bond - long wide shots of spectacularly set-up stunts, but it did have its moments (the plane sequence)
When Sam Mendes was brought on board for Skyfall there was a lot of hype about him being a "grown-up" director with "proper" films like American Beauty and Revolutionary Road under his belt (plus his big theatre background).
He didn't bring much to the table, frankly, and Skyfall failed on many points - Judi Dench at her worst, Javier Bardem looking a bit embarrassed at it all (and looking weirdly like Boris Johnson when he "disguised" himself as a bobby on the beat), James Bond on the tube, the nonsensical Aston Martin "reveal", the whole Home Alone finale etc, Q branch stupidly plugging the USB stick in, the terrible Heineken product placement etc.
Mendes on board again for Spectre....lots of hype about Christoph Waltz being in it...and what do they do but ditch all ideas of NOT being like Moore, and instead as mentioned earlier by me and echoed by yourself, they throw in a few "greatest hits" some of which worked, some of which didn't. But definitely we were sold "gritty and inventive and convincing" and they gave us: supercar chase around weirdly deserted streets; boring bit with aeroplane slowly disintegrating as it slides down some snow; drilling Bond's face; a single gunshot blowing up the complex; another single gunshot, from a pistol whilst standing on a boat in water bringing down a helicopter; and worst of all, the Bond girl literally tied to a bomb with a ticking countdown.
It's fair to say that our expectations WERE set higher than this.
Some of the past Bond films were actually pretty good:
My personal top four are From Russia With Love, On Her Majesty's Secret Service, For Your Eyes Only and The Living Daylights. Funnily enough, not many outlandish gadgets feature in those films and they all have a slightly gritty edge to them which is rather better done than in any of Daniel Craig's outings so far.