UKC

Barbara Ehrenreich

New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
 DaveHK 29 Oct 2018

I heard her on radio Scotland on Sunday morning and I must say she came across very well.

I hadn't heard of her before and don't know much about her.

What are folks opinions? Worthwhile buying one of her longer works and if so which one(s)?

Ta.

 Blue Straggler 31 Oct 2018
In reply to DaveHK:

I bought Nickel and Dimes for my Dad and I read a bit of the start of it - I admired her premise but it seemed that there a contrived falseness about her execution. I should not judge though, as I didn't read it all. My Dad was of the same opinion. 
I don't know her other works

 

 Hooo 31 Oct 2018
In reply to DaveHK:

I think Nickel and Dimed is well worth reading, I'm not sure why Straggler thought it was contrived, unless it's because she's a comfortably off writer posing as a menial worker in order to do the research - but that's the whole point of the book. It does  a good job of describing just how hard life is for poor people in the richest country in the world.

I've also read Dancing in the Streets and Smile or Die, I'd recommend both.

OP DaveHK 31 Oct 2018
In reply to Blue Straggler:

> I admired her premise but it seemed that there a contrived falseness about her execution.

You might be onto something there. After posting I read her essay 'Welcome to Cancerland'. It's about the infantilisation of breast cancer patients and the commodification of the disease. I too liked the premise but although I didn't find it contrived I didn't think she quite pulled it off. I got that she was angry but not enough insight into why she was angry.

Still good enough to make me want to try something else though.

OP DaveHK 31 Oct 2018
In reply to Hooo:

Thanks, I might download a sample to my kindle to see if I get on with it.

 Blue Straggler 31 Oct 2018
In reply to Hooo:

>  I'm not sure why Straggler thought it was contrived, unless it's because she's a comfortably off writer posing as a menial worker in order to do the research - but that's the whole point of the book.

Did you read my post properly? I openly admitted I had not read beyond the first 10 or so pages, I stated that I had therefore had no right to comment, and hopefully overall I put across the idea that I still praise Barbara. I only posted because the OP had not received any response for about 56 hours . Seems that I bumped the post usefully 

 

 Blue Straggler 04 Nov 2018
In reply to Hooo:

Also, genuine thanks for posting . I’ll look up those other works that you mention 

 Hooo 05 Nov 2018
In reply to Blue Straggler:

Thanks.

Despite my positive reviews, I should point out that Ehrenreich does have a pretty clear agenda in Nickel and Dimed. It's not a balanced view. She tries a similar approach for white collar workers in Bait and Switch, but I didn't find that nearly as convincing.

 Roberttaylor 07 Nov 2018
In reply to Hooo:

I thought Nickel and Dimed was (is) well worth a read but I too found it s bit too full of the author, if that makes sense. Gonzo journalism obviously has this as a core component but I didn't think she came across particularly well; I agree with the thrust of her argument (being poor in America is a grim trap) but I don't think the author would be much fun at a party.

It's less to the point than The Road to Wigan peir, for example.

Post edited at 08:28
 Hooo 07 Nov 2018
In reply to Roberttaylor:

Do you think Orwell would be much fun at a party?

I did snort with laughter at the bit at the end of Wigan Pier where he rants about vegetarian cranks in the socialist movement.

 Roberttaylor 08 Nov 2018
In reply to Hooo:

He'd be less sanctimonious than Barbera but yeah, judging by the rest of his work I suspect he'd drag the tone down a bit.

I'd forgotten about that part!


New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
Loading Notifications...