In reply to schloosh:
Really good work. A word of warning though is that given all the excellent low grade bouldering you could do with a full blast with a lower grade team as quite a few lower grades look odd (more than one full grade up and down so its not just a grade border issue) and sometimes too low on problems where you dont want to be sandbagged. Although you have sorted out some of the rare scary lower grade undergrades in the BMC guide (like Space Trip/High Traverse given V0- 4c where we'd agree with you and say its a full on and scary V0/F5; but then as an example of a big undergrade 8 is also solid 4 at least).
I've done pretty much all the easier stuff now from the Huddersfield guide with consistent agreement from Lynn, Rick Gibbon, Chris Tan and other experienced guidebook folk who know their onions, so I am more than likely right. I think such issues arise with the conflation of differences of opinion with the multiple grade conversions (UK tech to V to Font) so given the quality of the lower grade stuff we went back and did them all after the BMC guide was out. Our stuff for Standedge will be going live on the updated Offwidth soonish. Also did most of West Nab.
