> (In reply to GoCragging.com)
> There is no doubt the beals handle better and have a lower impact force from new.
>
> I'd love to see some stats on ropes after they been used a couple of years and washed several times, replicating climbing in winter and rinsing after sea cliffs. The dry coating does wear off somewhat and its partly that that keeps the impact force low on fully dry treated ropes. Also rinsing ropes to some degree bonds the sheath to the core which must also effect things.
>
> Anyway I don't think there is a clear winner it's just down to what you prefer.
I'd love to see those stats too
I doubt they'll ever happen though
I'm not sure about the dry treatment playing a part in keeping a low impact force. Unless you mean the dry treatment protecting the sheath and core from external agents and therefore helping the rope retaining its dynamic properties. That's definitely the aim of such treatments, although, as you say, it really matters when climbing, for example, sea cliffs, but also ice, snow, etc. it probably matters more for UK climbers than for the average continental crag hopper.
I agree, there isn't a clear winner between the Cobra II and the Joker. They belong to different categories after all. When I bought the Joker I was really looking for a skinny 100 m rope that would not weigh tonnes on my shoulders and it seemed the right choice at the time. Nowadays there are even skinnier and lighter single or triple rated ropes around whose sheath behave better than the Joker's.
Btw, I forgot to say that my Joker is not the latest Unicore version, while the Cobra II's are the new Unicore ones, manufactured in 2013. Even harder (or nonsensical) to compare them...
I'm still not completely sold on the "triple rated" concept. I'm not very good at judging these things though as the numbers seem to tell me either people love skinny triple rated ropes or manufacturers have very good reasons to push the sales of skinny triple rated ropes.
As you say, going with what we prefer, sounds very sensible indeed
Nic