In reply to pwhitmarsh:
Currently looking for a new mat as well. My two pennies worth having owned a few (albeit cheaper ones, mainly Alpkit) and fallen on a few more:
Ocun Dominator - well made, thick, big, versatile, expensive. You see alot of them around for a very good reason. A safe choice if you don't mind the cost.
Snap, Organic, Petzl - always think of these as fairly top end brands, pretty cool etc, not sure you get a great deal more for your money in some cases.
Psychi - I'm intrigued by these. Outwardly they look very good for the money, and well designed. The tri fold ones looks huge. I've seen a few in use, but not tried one. They seem to be gaining a following. I'd like to know how durable the outer is, and what the foam quality is like.
Also, perhaps stating the obvious here, but having two mats (or more) is often very useful. Great for traverses, high balls, covering awkwardly placed boulders etc.
Post edited at 16:36