I'll report back after the weekend of dry tooling if they hold up or not.
Turns out this thread is now archived so can't resurrect it.
Anyway spurred on by the other post about Nomics, I'd just like to add that the pair fixed in the link above are still fixed having done three routes in Scotland involving a fair bit of swinging into rock under powder when you think it will stick and it just bounces right back. Also done a couple of laps on Blood line and First Blood down at Hodge Close and another day dry tooling and they are still totally solid.
From the old thread as well I now find prefer my X Dreams to the Nomic for Scotland, hard to say why. Have a few bruised knuckles from using the Nomics which I never get with the X Dreams. Maybe it's the narrower head on the X Dream... The Nomics were definitely better at Hodge Close though.