In reply to Removed User:
As a Cardiff fan, I was surprised by his initial appointment and even more surprised by the results he achieved.
When he was our manager, we saw no evidence of tactical ability, no ability to motivate the dressing room and an awful recruitment process which involved paying (for us) huge sums on unproven players who never made it for us and were offloaded after his sacking for huge losses, often after barely playing a game for the club. I think I'm right in saying that not a single one of his signings is still at the club. Had he not been sacked during his first full season, I am in no doubt that we would have been relegated to League One.
Maybe he has learned since then, maybe he is more effective when managing a highly talented team, or maybe the results so far are mainly down to a massive short term increase in morale after a club legend replaced a toxic motivational drain.
I could be wrong but I'm not expecting United to be in the title race this time next year. Having someone else being in charge of recruitment will be essential if you want to return to challenging at the top.