In reply to Mr Plow:
> Or at least doesn't attempt to cast any shadow over a manufactured route on yorkshire limestone in aprils review of 2010's goings on. Does anyone else think this is a bit odd?
No not odd at all. It is in a report by Kevin Avery who is reporting about a route climbed by Jordan Buys.
So no, Climb Magazine or their editors do not comment whether it is OK to manufacture routes/create holds.
Kevin writes:
'Jordan set about working the unclimbed extension to
The Sound of One Hand Slapping, itself a short 7c.
The Jordanator eventually succumbed to a powerful and bouldery 8b sequence using a drilled pocket/seam to gain a heuco pocket and a final testing sequence to the belay.'
It also makes no accusation to who drilled the pocket/seam.
That extension did have bolt-on holds for a while (1992/93). I put them there and they were promptly removed, thank goodness. I was the the first ascensionist of
The Sound of One Hand Slapping.
Mick