In reply to Double Knee Bar:
> (In reply to Ramblin dave) crack and corner at The Roaches. Gets S but everyone knows it's a hard HS really.
Right Hand Route seems similar - getting an "I beg your pardon?" S4b in the definitive...
But I'm going off topic on my own thread, there.
I haven't lead a proper grit VS yet, so I don't know if it qualifies, but about the scariest HS I've done was Verandah Pillar at Stanage - it looks like a classic nice little HS with a difficult start followed by a well protected jug haul up the flake, but then you get to the flake and find that it's neither well protected nor juggy.
Cleft wall route one seemed pretty desperate when I seconded it too, although that's maybe because I didn't "get" grit at that point. I can imagine a lot of technically harder routes feeling a bit more relaxing, though.